cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/54992042
Nov. 5, 2026
The poll says 66 percent of Jewish voters in the US believe that Aipacās campaign spending against candidates who criticise Israel actually increases antisemitism in the country.
In addition, 60 percent believe that Jewish organisations that label harsh criticism of Israel as antisemitic are exploiting concerns about antisemitism to defend unpopular Israeli government policies.
Notably, 80 percent of Jewish voters believe that Israelās actions in the occupied West Bank and Gaza are increasing antisemitism in the US.
My very Jewish friend in high school, a vehement antizionist, said that truly beating antisemitism doesnāt mean one place Jews are safe, but having Jews be safe everywhere.
Hard to disagree with that. Furthermore, itād be lovely if that was equally true for everybody else too.
Less likely than spontaneous pink unicorns happening, but definitely lovely.
And Iām not even sure they are all that safe in Israel. Or their actions donāt seem to indicate that they feel safe.
In any case, I am quite sure that this notion of a relationship that no one could ever question in this country (until fairly recently) stoked a metric shit-ton of antisemitism here.
People have a really hard time with the nuance of āI hate that Iām funding a country like Israel no matter what their actions are and no matter how I vote. Also, Iāll be labeled an āantisemiteā and lambasted for this criticism.ā Some people in that camp may not really be able to tell the difference between what the country of Israel is doing vs. what āthe Jews are up toā. And so some fall into outright antisemitism.
I do have to say a bunch of people lording it over others that no one could say shit without being drummed out of polite society does build up a lot of resentment. And people are right to be deeply resentful. It just needs to be aimed at those that are to blame, though. I mean, we donāt even have universal healthcare here, but Israel does? Why the fuck are we sending so much money to them?
And Iām not even sure they are all that safe in Israel. Or their actions donāt seem to indicate that they feel safe.
Their actions have directly caused them feeling less safe.
When you forcibly take away territory from a neighboring people so you can give it to āsettlersā from your country, you generate resentment and anger.
When you label an entire population as terrorists and kill a large portion of their people you create the next generation of angry orphans who will seek revenge against you.
Their morbid plan had one flaw: unlike Europeans in North America, they didnāt outright exterminate all the natives upon their arrival, they merely decimated and displaced them. The resentment stems from being neighbors with people who stole your land. Even the French were better at conolizing North Africa: they stole the land and decimated the population, but then they employed the natives and let them live there. It allowed them to stay a bit longer than otherwise. In the end they were kicked out after a bloody war of emancipation against apartheid and oppression.
Honestly the deeply contested Middle Eastern Holylands, seems like a really dumb place to go for a sense of safety.
Let me see, has humanity ever faught over religion before? Gee I wonder.
You gotta look at it from the perspective of the original Zionists in the 1890ās. A big part of why we view the Middle East as a religiously/ideologically fraught region is because of the effects of Zionist settlers moving in and starting conflicts. When the Zionists first moved in, Palestine was a pretty peaceful and relatively backwater territory of the Ottoman Empire (side note, most of the land the Zionists ālegallyā purchased was from Ottoman absentee landlords, not actual Palestinian folks; if Palestine hadnāt already veen part of an Empire, and had already had self-determination, the whole thing probably never would have happened). And European colonialism was still socially acceptable as a ācivilizing forceā to many people (at least in Europe) at the time.
What a kumbaya moment. Did it include American Universities?
Well, they are not wrongā¦
Turns out the diaspora can see the Nazism far better than the nazis themselves, no matter how hard the nazis try to equate their existence.
Sounds like a bunch of antisemitic Jewish people! /s
Be aware also that AIPAC changed their name to United Democracy Project (UDP).
By Democracy they mean like how the Democratic Peopleās Republic of Korea are a democracy right?
Same as the National Socialist German Workersā Party
No like how the USA and Israel are democracies. With massive lobbying and foreign interference.
They have many super pacs they use to funnel money to dems without being noticed immediately.
This is why , as a good rule of thumb, any politician getting a lot from PACS means they likely are either 1. Bought by companies. 2. Bought by Israel. Or 3. Both.
Vote for Dems who get most of their donations from small individual donations.
Large individual donations could just be corporations or aipac trying to hide who gave the money.
Here are some of aipacs āsecretā PACS.
Source: https://www.trackaipac.com/about/aipac
There are probably many not yet found out. Especially smaller ones or newer ones.
Many do not say āIsraelā nor āJewishā in the name and just sound like progressive groups. Many imply they are for minorities and women politicians.



Yeah, no shit. The āJews control the worldā thing is pure antisemitism, but itās honestly sounding more and more reasonable for people to believe it when a Jewish State is behind things like anti-BDS laws, and the deplatforming of Macklemore.
And for those of us who know that Israel ā Jews, there are AIPAC members insisting the opposite.
Itās honestly hard work resisting antisemitic ideas when there are Jewish organizations trying to prove old harmful stereotypes right for some reason.
It fucking sucks.
Israel isnāt even the one driving. Itās Western capitalists and their need for an imperialist stronghold in the Middle East. Israel is a puppet state enacting the will of (mostly US) imperialists.
Israel has been a majority rightwing voting country for over 30 years now. Most polls show them as consistently 60 - 70% rightwing.
Itās both
Israel is enacting its own will, and is being by supported by the west because their goals align
Good to hear. This is the kind of news that actually fights antisemitism.
Antisemitism is the lifeblood of Israel, itās absolutely necessary to justify their continued existence as an unaccountable genocidal apartheid state, freely ratfucking your media and political institutions and paid for by your tax dollars.
Yeah, itās rather obvious.
It hasnāt been obvious to previous generations of US Jews, so this is a big deal, and gives the Palestinian solidarity movement a big opportunity.
Well, Israel isnāt really projecting an image of Jews being decent peopleā¦
I actually thought AIPAC was some antisemitic conspiracy theory when someone first explained it to me.
It is an antisemitic conspiracy. The Zionistsā insistence that Israel is for and by all Jews is an attempt to implicate all Jews in the genocide to avoid criticism.
AIPAC is used by the far right to argue that the jews control America as a puppet state. Some of the more insane leftists (e.g. BadEmpanada) believe the same thing but uses the term āZionistā as a dog whistle. So, itās understandable that you would dismiss itās existence as a conspiracy theory
ISRAEL IS ON STOLEN PALESTINIAN LAND
Will they say that on CNN, MSNBC, Fox, CBS?
We used to have too many channels. Now we only have one.
Over 100 years ago a president broke up a shit ton of monopolies and virtually every child in America still has a stuffed animal named after himā¦
A big part of why people are so pessimistic these days, is theyāre ignorant that weāve fixed these problems before and can do it again, even when we still carry the cultural remnants in our day today lives.
At this point itās honestly not even hard, just gotta get people to vote in the 28 primaries.
And a Republican no less.
Again, that only seems weird because neoliberals sold out our party for 30 yearsā¦
They kept moving right to please corps and oligarchs, but it was slow so Republicans couldnāt leap frog them and switch. It just drove them straight to extremism.
None of that was a coincidence.
But neoliberals lost the party almost two years ago, thatās why Tuesday happened. Republican party will have to move back to center or be replaced by a new party. And the chaos that would cause would be enough to really fix our government.
Jewish Voices for Peace, and other would. The corporate news wonāt let them.
Do you think AIPAC funding a Super PAC that runs campaign ads against candidates who criticize Israel increases antisemitism in the United States?
Uhā¦
Itās weird to act like AIPAC is the start of it, or that they donāt control the super PAC they raise donations for. Israel funds AIPAC to solicit donations for itās Super PAC, UDP.
Until 2021, AIPAC did not raise funds for political candidates itself; its members raised money for candidates through political action committees unaffiliated with AIPAC and by other means.[which?][6] In late 2021, AIPAC formed its own political action committee, AIPAC PAC, and announced plans for a super PAC, the United Democracy Project, which can spend money on candidatesā behalf.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIPAC
The Israeli government is AIPAC and AIPAC is UDP.
Itās effectively the same single entity.
Quick edit:
Also, itās a J street poll, and thereās some red flags in there too, stuff like asking what year respondents were born in, then the options are ages.
But if you donāt know what J Street is, theyāre Zionist lobbyists, literally, I donāt mean that in the way the word gets thrown around.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J_Street
If AIPAC is MAGA, J Street are neoliberals, same destination, just different speeds to get to there.
With rightwing losses in both Israel and America, look for them to fill AIPACs role by 2028. If for no other reason than current toxic branding.
ā¦thatās because they do, which in turn is because it is an enormously beneficial lever for them
Talk about it talk about it talk about it talk about it
Correct
Cool do they think Israel should not exist?
The criticism is more that Israel being explicitly the āJewish stateā makes their political atrocities linked to people who just share the religion. The possibility of this happening was actually a point of criticism by some jewish people before the creation of Israel: It turns a religious and cultural identity into a political one, which has mutated zionism into an ethnonationalist ideology.
Well no, the criticism is whether it looks bad on Jews. Not about committing atrocities on others.
The question they should ask is whether Israel should exist or not.
I never know what people mean by āIsreal should not exist.ā its a comment very open to interpretation. Do you mean the government should not exist? Its people should disappear?
I think Israel could exist if it wasnāt a imperialist religious ethnostate, the problem is the government and who it leaves out. If Israel included all Palestine and all citizens as equal partners in its government it could most certainly exist. Its never going to happen in our lifetime, but a one state solution is the only solution that doesnāt involve genocide as a prerequisite of success, IMO.
The government should not exist, of course.
Decolonialization is not genocide this is a ridiculous notion. Palestinians own all the land there and all the properties on it. The thieves will have to return the property and leave.
However, because Palestinians are very nice people, they might be willing to accept colonists staying on the land as long as they disband their apartheid state.
Iām curious how far you think that extends? At least some percentage of the Israeli Jews, Israeli Palestinians, and Israeli Christians currently benefitting from colonization trace their ancestry to Isreal prior to the creation of the state, are they to be ādecolonizedā from the only land their family has ever known? What about people who are 2-3 generations in, they are to rely on the kindness of Palestinians when they take over? If Palestinians take over, are they now the new religious ethnostate?
There is no question that Israel is a amoral colonialist religious ethnostate. But if the solution involves removing people from the region youāll end up in a very familiar scenario i would call genocide the minute it gets violent. I think whether it sounds fair or not there has to be some restorative justice for Palestinians rather than purely punitive action to Israeli citizens. If decolonization in your mind involves removing Jews from Israel entirely I think youāve lost me. Focus on rebuilding communities and seizing land more recently taken by violence this generation, or within what is now occupied Palestinian land.
Israeli Palestinians
You misspelled Palestinians living under Apartheid.
I said removing colonizers not Jews.
Probably not, but this is huge progress.
Progress is when they believe in a working solution. Such as disbanding the apartheid. Not when they feel something is slightly problematic for their own perception.













