They could make ISPs block it so that you’d need a VPN to access the service, which would make it infeasible for huge swathes of its userbase, which would kill the ability for many of the rest to use it to communicate with the people they need to.
IMO you are right. And you’re calling out something I wish more people got.
When a sovereign blocks things, ppl always say, “It’s fine! Imma chain VPNs and recompile from source and double-ROT13 my connections!!!”
This isn’t about technical bypasses. It is never iron clad. You can get past national firewalls in the most draconian places on earth. But a few simple measures will stop 99%. If the other 1% become a problem, they can crank up the pain, until most of those stop too.
Canada has strong personal freedoms and low levels of corruption. But in more authoritarian societies, you can even face major risks to yourself, for using what was banned. Most ppl will decide the risk is too much.
I’ve not heard of canadian ISPs actually blocking anything… i heard of legal battles over torrenting sites but never heard of an ISP actually blocking anything
I should have been clearer, I can’t speak for Canada directly. I meant more generally around the world, DNS blocking is a common mechanism for enforcement.
They could make ISPs block it so that you’d need a VPN to access the service, which would make it infeasible for huge swathes of its userbase, which would kill the ability for many of the rest to use it to communicate with the people they need to.
IMO you are right. And you’re calling out something I wish more people got.
When a sovereign blocks things, ppl always say, “It’s fine! Imma chain VPNs and recompile from source and double-ROT13 my connections!!!”
This isn’t about technical bypasses. It is never iron clad. You can get past national firewalls in the most draconian places on earth. But a few simple measures will stop 99%. If the other 1% become a problem, they can crank up the pain, until most of those stop too.
Canada has strong personal freedoms and low levels of corruption. But in more authoritarian societies, you can even face major risks to yourself, for using what was banned. Most ppl will decide the risk is too much.
How is an ISP supposed to block only signal servers hosted on AWS?
block DNS queries for signal domains?
Yeah, DNS block is probably the most common way. There are ways around that, but it’s not something most people are going to want to fight with .
Edit: I should be clearer, I mean most common globally, I can’t speak for Canada specifically.
I’ve not heard of canadian ISPs actually blocking anything… i heard of legal battles over torrenting sites but never heard of an ISP actually blocking anything
I should have been clearer, I can’t speak for Canada directly. I meant more generally around the world, DNS blocking is a common mechanism for enforcement.
I’m guessing this is their plan. It seems to be the go-to method for governments.