Getting banned from ml is routine. Hexbear will hate you regardless of anything. Startrek.website is run by a complete nutter. Tankies are everywhere. Double check that community you see in All before you comment. Eat fruit.
I came to the comments specifically because I knew some people would be trying to poison a newcomer with bullshit about the actual leftist instances here. Hexbear only hates you if you are a racist, nazi, troll, etc, or coming to wreck. Come ask questions about imperialism or “tankies” or anything at all in good faith, you might be surprised.
Come ask questions about imperialism or “tankies” or anything at all in good faith, you might be surprised.
I’m gonna have to disagree. As someone who has wandered into Hexbear and .ml threads on multiple occasions without realizing it, asking questions did not yield positive interactions. Whenever this comes up and I talk about my experiences, I always get Hexbear or .ml users who try to downplay it, imply it’s just wounded ego, insist I must have been rude/hateful/belligerent, etc. Those communities very quickly turn hostile if you express anything other than already understanding and agreeing with them.
Also you aren’t wrong about the quickness to hostility at times, part of that comes from most users on hexbear having been berated for their views essentially everywhere else they could possibly express them, it’s easy to get overly defensive.
Do you have an example of one of the questions? I agree users that post there can be hostile, and some could use more patience before jumping to accusations of trolling or whatever, but honestly everytime I’ve seen someone say this sentiment it turns out they were being racist, using slurs, or didn’t understand how what they posted was racist or imperialist propaganda and doubled down with hostility when called out.
I had a hell of a time getting any sort of source on the claim that Ukraine is full of and/or run by Nazis, for example. I don’t remember the exact wording I used, but I generally tried to be polite and inquisitive, just looking for more information on the claim rather than trying to refute it. I was open to being shown evidence that it was true, and I tried not to imply that I was somehow set in believing otherwise.
I still had to ask like 6 times in various different threads I saw it come up in to get a single decent source. The best I got all but the last time, and not even every time, was a few pictures of a few dozen people around Nazi flags and insignia, and while it’s shit that those people are congregating and feel safe taking those pictures, I didn’t want to extrapolate from less than 50 people to an entire nation, including their leadership. I received dozens of comments insulting and belittling me, accusing me of Nazi apologia for not taking those pics as proof against the whole nation, etc. I finally got one person to share a couple articles about it, and they could best be summed up as “Ukraine has tolerated some shit they definitely shouldn’t have, perhaps for the sake of not alienating willing fighters for the war since they’re under active invasion, and that’s not okay, but .ml and Hexbear still exaggerate a lot.”
There are full books about the far-right issue in Ukraine, Ukrainian neo-nazi groups were key to escalating the violence during the unrest in 2014, commiting false-flag murders against leftist activists and police while the Western advisors and their chosen new administration for Ukraine ignored the claims. The state of Ukraine has given official honors to groups who collaborated with the Nazis in WW2. And the images you mention are part of the evidence, the fact that neo-nazi symbols are commonplace among troops is a red flag and points to the tolerance for fascism in Ukraine.
Neo-Nazi networks are deeply embedded in parts of Ukraine’s military structure. Their presence is visible in units such as Azov, the Third Assault Brigade, the Russian Volunteer Corps, Bratstvo, the German Volunteer Corps, Karpatska Sich, and others. Yet Ukraine’s Western backers continue to arm, fund, and train these units without meaningful scrutiny.
If you came away saying hexbear exaggerates a lot it is completely unsurprising you were banned, in what way are their claims exaggerated?
This open access book examines the Russia-Ukraine war and its origins. Based on analysis of a large number of primary and secondary sources, it provides a systematic analysis of this crucial war, its nature, outcome, possibility of peaceful settlement, violence against civilians, and origins. The book examines the role of such factors as the NATO accession of Ukraine, Russian imperialism, democracy, genocide, and the far-right in the start of the war and traces the conflict escalation ladder, which culminated in this war, to preceding violent conflicts in Ukraine, in particular, the Euromaidan, the Maidan massacre, the Russian annexation of Crimea, and the war in Donbas.
There are full books about the far-right issue in Ukraine, Ukrainian neo-nazi groups were key to escalating the violence during the unrest in 2014, commiting false-flag murders against leftist activists and police while the Western advisors and their chosen new administration for Ukraine ignored the claims.
Quite possibly, I don’t know a lot about Ukraine, which is part of why I tried to approach it with an open mind. However, I would point out that for all the vitriol I received, I don’t recall anyone suggesting any books at all.
And the images you mention are part of the evidence, the fact that neo-nazi symbols are commonplace among troops is a red flag and points to the tolerance for fascism in Ukraine.
I never attempted to refute the images or what they show. I merely did not accept images of less than 50 people as proof of a systemic issue.
If you came away saying hexbear exaggerates a lot it is completely unsurprising you were banned, in what way are their claims exaggerated?
I didn’t get banned, just faced a lot of hostility for asking about it at all. Again, while trying to be open minded and inquisitive, not hurling insults or trying to call the whole thing bullshit. There was effectively no discussion of my reaction to the evidence itself. With the sole exception of the person who provided a couple articles on the topic, everyone else only commented on my request for info and my refusal to accept those few pictures as complete evidence of a systemic issue.
As for how the claims appeared exaggerated in light of what was provided to me, the articles that were eventually linked for me didn’t corroborate claims that Nazis as a faction have significant influence over the government, nor did they match the claimed extent of their prevalence. It did, however, support claims that the government had effectively looked the other way and tolerated some Nazi/fascist violence. However, since all the incidents it spoke of were from after the invasion, I find it difficult to tell if that’s because the Ukrainian government overall tacitly supports them or if they’re simply afraid to push back on a relatively militant faction that’s willing to actually help them fight back invaders. That’s not to say that it’s ever a good idea to look the other way, but I can at least understand a difference between supporting them and feeling the need to choose their battles in the moment. I still think that even under the most charitable interpretation, it’s a cursed bargain akin to trying to weaponize a rabid dog, very likely to end terribly for the one who tries to hold the leash, though.
Hexbear has a reputation it has earned on its own. Its nothing to do with “poisoning against leftists” and three damned seconds in my comment history would have clued you as to where i stand politically anyway
I heard that rep, and then I made a hexbear account and primarily post from there. It’s the biggest hawk of shit that is usually only said by reactionaries that were mad they got banned for using slurs. And looking at your profile you’re right, you’d be banned for racism, as I was saying, hexbear doesn’t tolerate racism.
Getting banned from ml is routine. Hexbear will hate you regardless of anything. Startrek.website is run by a complete nutter. Tankies are everywhere. Double check that community you see in All before you comment. Eat fruit.
I came to the comments specifically because I knew some people would be trying to poison a newcomer with bullshit about the actual leftist instances here. Hexbear only hates you if you are a racist, nazi, troll, etc, or coming to wreck. Come ask questions about imperialism or “tankies” or anything at all in good faith, you might be surprised.
I’m gonna have to disagree. As someone who has wandered into Hexbear and .ml threads on multiple occasions without realizing it, asking questions did not yield positive interactions. Whenever this comes up and I talk about my experiences, I always get Hexbear or .ml users who try to downplay it, imply it’s just wounded ego, insist I must have been rude/hateful/belligerent, etc. Those communities very quickly turn hostile if you express anything other than already understanding and agreeing with them.
Also you aren’t wrong about the quickness to hostility at times, part of that comes from most users on hexbear having been berated for their views essentially everywhere else they could possibly express them, it’s easy to get overly defensive.
Do you have an example of one of the questions? I agree users that post there can be hostile, and some could use more patience before jumping to accusations of trolling or whatever, but honestly everytime I’ve seen someone say this sentiment it turns out they were being racist, using slurs, or didn’t understand how what they posted was racist or imperialist propaganda and doubled down with hostility when called out.
I had a hell of a time getting any sort of source on the claim that Ukraine is full of and/or run by Nazis, for example. I don’t remember the exact wording I used, but I generally tried to be polite and inquisitive, just looking for more information on the claim rather than trying to refute it. I was open to being shown evidence that it was true, and I tried not to imply that I was somehow set in believing otherwise.
I still had to ask like 6 times in various different threads I saw it come up in to get a single decent source. The best I got all but the last time, and not even every time, was a few pictures of a few dozen people around Nazi flags and insignia, and while it’s shit that those people are congregating and feel safe taking those pictures, I didn’t want to extrapolate from less than 50 people to an entire nation, including their leadership. I received dozens of comments insulting and belittling me, accusing me of Nazi apologia for not taking those pics as proof against the whole nation, etc. I finally got one person to share a couple articles about it, and they could best be summed up as “Ukraine has tolerated some shit they definitely shouldn’t have, perhaps for the sake of not alienating willing fighters for the war since they’re under active invasion, and that’s not okay, but .ml and Hexbear still exaggerate a lot.”
There are full books about the far-right issue in Ukraine, Ukrainian neo-nazi groups were key to escalating the violence during the unrest in 2014, commiting false-flag murders against leftist activists and police while the Western advisors and their chosen new administration for Ukraine ignored the claims. The state of Ukraine has given official honors to groups who collaborated with the Nazis in WW2. And the images you mention are part of the evidence, the fact that neo-nazi symbols are commonplace among troops is a red flag and points to the tolerance for fascism in Ukraine.
https://responsiblestatecraft.org/nazis-in-ukraine-military/
If you came away saying hexbear exaggerates a lot it is completely unsurprising you were banned, in what way are their claims exaggerated?
This is a link to a paper with a PDF download by a well-known, widely-cited researcher of the war, describing the origins of the conflict and how the far-right played a key role.
Quite possibly, I don’t know a lot about Ukraine, which is part of why I tried to approach it with an open mind. However, I would point out that for all the vitriol I received, I don’t recall anyone suggesting any books at all.
I never attempted to refute the images or what they show. I merely did not accept images of less than 50 people as proof of a systemic issue.
I didn’t get banned, just faced a lot of hostility for asking about it at all. Again, while trying to be open minded and inquisitive, not hurling insults or trying to call the whole thing bullshit. There was effectively no discussion of my reaction to the evidence itself. With the sole exception of the person who provided a couple articles on the topic, everyone else only commented on my request for info and my refusal to accept those few pictures as complete evidence of a systemic issue.
As for how the claims appeared exaggerated in light of what was provided to me, the articles that were eventually linked for me didn’t corroborate claims that Nazis as a faction have significant influence over the government, nor did they match the claimed extent of their prevalence. It did, however, support claims that the government had effectively looked the other way and tolerated some Nazi/fascist violence. However, since all the incidents it spoke of were from after the invasion, I find it difficult to tell if that’s because the Ukrainian government overall tacitly supports them or if they’re simply afraid to push back on a relatively militant faction that’s willing to actually help them fight back invaders. That’s not to say that it’s ever a good idea to look the other way, but I can at least understand a difference between supporting them and feeling the need to choose their battles in the moment. I still think that even under the most charitable interpretation, it’s a cursed bargain akin to trying to weaponize a rabid dog, very likely to end terribly for the one who tries to hold the leash, though.
Nah mate.
Hexbear has a reputation it has earned on its own. Its nothing to do with “poisoning against leftists” and three damned seconds in my comment history would have clued you as to where i stand politically anyway
I heard that rep, and then I made a hexbear account and primarily post from there. It’s the biggest hawk of shit that is usually only said by reactionaries that were mad they got banned for using slurs. And looking at your profile you’re right, you’d be banned for racism, as I was saying, hexbear doesn’t tolerate racism.