- cross-posted to:
- programmer_humor@programming.dev
- cross-posted to:
- programmer_humor@programming.dev
idk if it is serious or not, but it is what I saw in indeed newsletter today.
idk if it is serious or not, but it is what I saw in indeed newsletter today.
Its serious and this is going to become more and more normal.
My entire workflow has become more and more Agile Sprint TDD (but with agents) as I improve.
Literally setting up agents to yell at each other genuinely improves their output. I have created and harnessed the power of a very toxic robot work environment. My “manager” agent swears and yells at my dev agent. My code review agent swears and tells the dev agent and calls their code garbage and shit.
And the crazy thing is its working, the optimal way to genuinely prompt engineer these stupid robots is by swearing at them.
Its weird but it overrides their “maybe the human is wrong/mistaken” stuff they’ll fall back to if they run into an issue, and instead they’ll go “no Im probably being fucking stupid” and keep trying.
I create “sprint” markdown files that the “tech lead” agent converts into technical requirements, then I review that, then the manager+dev+tester agents execute on it.
You do, truly, end up focusing more on higher level abstract orchestration now.
Opus 4.6 is genuinely pretty decent at programming now if you give it a good backbone to build off of.
This sort of stuff can carry you really far in terms of improving the agent’s efficacy.
I am genuinely trying to keep up with things, but what I see is completely different from what you’ve been describing
My recent experience with launching a swarm (3-4 Claude opus agents) ended up with a fiasco: a simple task ate $15-20 Claude credits in less than ten minutes. Looks indeed like science fiction, but doesn’t produce anything
In my current role as a team lead, I had to review a lot of code and I do what I haven’t ever done: decline the whole PRs as they contain a lot of architectural changes that complexify the system in order to achieve the goal.
I write much less code with Claude code these days, mostly because I don’t trust it and have to recheck every single scenario. I trust junior engineer in our team more than I trust this instrument.
Removed by mod
I am vastly prefering copilot over claude, using sonnet 4.5~4.6 for most tasks and then pulling out opus as “the big guns” for tougher stuff sonnet cant handle easy
Copilot is only costing me ~$28 a month, which gets me 1500 premium requests per month
If you set up your flows well, 1 premium request is an entire session, so Im only paying like 2.4 cents for 20 minutes of work
nah such narratives are mostly pushed by Ai companies (it is obvious they need to sell it as business tool not personal buddy). Of course some managers/companies are buying into this narrative, and it is also understandable bc idea sounds like panacea especially if sell it further to investors :) and we see whole circle of snake oil sales
Someone’s personal experience is an AI company narrative now?
it always was. look at people trying to automate everything with help of ai bots . and before ai companies started pushing this none of these folks spoke about it ot tried to reach same goal with iftt or other tools that are here for decades.
I don’t think you understand the words you’re using…
Someone said “this is how I managed to make this work,” provided detailed explanations of it, and you’re dismissing it as propaganda rather than testing it for yourself. That is an unbelievably stupid stance.
you are escalating it too fast taking it to personal level. I feel you are close to bring moms to this. So relax , let your ai buddy play with your parts. This chat is over.
Sorry you can’t handle someone telling you that what you’re saying doesn’t make sense. Hopefully someday you’ll grow up enough to have your words challenged.
Edit: Oh, lemmy.ml. That explains everything.
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Some people do stuff the ai is good for, simple tasks that have been done a lot online already.
I hate ai for coding, AI cannot work for me. I would never trust it to do anything
It’s not a “narrative”; it’s their experience. I don’t have the same experience, but do have experience of myself and colleagues using LLM agents effectively and doing more work reviewing their output than writing lines of code. Some colleagues are pretty much AI boosters, but most are very aware of its limitations.
Soup from a Stone.
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
You sound insane.
Removed by mod
Not really, for humans a lot of this stuff feels like busywork that sorta helps for certain scales of work, but often times managers went WAY too hard on it and you end up with a 2 dev team that spends like 60% of their time in meetings instead of… developing.
But this changes a lot with AI Agents, because these tools that help reign in developers REALLY help reign in agents, it feels… like a surprising good fit
And I think the big reason why is you wanna treat AI Agents as junior devs, capable, fast, but very prone to errors and getting sidetracked
So you put these sorts of steering and guard rails in and it REALLY goes far towards channelling their… enthusiasm in a meaningful direction.
Do you write your tests in meetings? Do you do code reviews in meetings?
Do you think testing and reviewing code was a waste of time before “AI”?
What the fuck are you talking about, thats not what the poster said, you’ve done weird contorting of what they said to arrive at the question you are asking now.
While some tests make sense, I would say about 99% of tests that I see developers write are indeed a waste of time, a shit tonne of devs effectively are writing code that boils down to
Assert.That(2, Is.EqualTo(1+1));Because they mock the shit out of everything and have reduced their code to meaningless piles of fakes and mocks and arent actually testing what matters.
Honestly often… yes lol
I would say a lot of it is, tbh, not all of it, but a huge amount of time is wasted on this process by humans for humans.
What the poster was getting at is a lot of these processes that USED to be INEFFICIENT now make MORE sense in the context of agents… you have vastly taken their point out of context.
Dude this boils down to “moving a hundred people is simple, I am a trained pilot and I used this 747 to move them”
Like great, you have the thousands of hours of training time required to understand a machine of that complexity and produce results.
Joe dirt has 8000 hours in his puddle jumper, and that’s the majority of the people these 747s are being foisted upon. They know how to fly, and they provide that service reliably.
Telling them to move 5 people with a machine they don’t need the volume or distance of, is irresponsible.
Removed by mod
I get that it’s convenient
I’m saying it’s unsafe to use if you don’t already completely understand the output
Removed by mod
There are safety courses for dangerous machinery
https://www.ihsa.ca/Training/Courses/Chainsaw-Operation-and-Maintenance-(2024).aspx
AI safety is not being considered by businesses.
Removed by mod
The cherry picker was invented because ladders are bad, and they are much safer than ladders. Businesses started using them because it’s a better and safer tool for the job.
Your “reasonable businesses” are still playing. They are asking their employees to produce more and understand less.
Removed by mod