Opponents say [Washington state] voters were persuaded at least partly because the initiative and its boosters exploited deep-seated prejudices and misunderstandings about transgender people to erode their rights.
Opponents say [Washington state] voters were persuaded at least partly because the initiative and its boosters exploited deep-seated prejudices and misunderstandings about transgender people to erode their rights.
Because youāre not thinking big enough. The ātrans sportsā debate is literally just bigotry. Seriously, go watch the John Oliver piece on it. Every study that has ever been done has found that any advantage trans women and girls have disappears after a few years of hormone therapy. The athletic performance of trans women is well within the range of that of cis women. Believing trans women should be banned from womenās sports because they have an unfair advantage has no more scientific validity to it than the old racist beliefs that black athletes couldnāt compete fairly in white leagues. The science has been. The studies have been performed. Cis people just refuse to believe them. Their gut feelings outweigh science and our humanity.
People just vote based on bigotry. Even most liberal āalliesā are awful at this. Most liberal allies just see trans women as drag queens, literal men in dresses, as if we donāt take medications that completely reshape our bodies on a biochemical level. Morons, even many moronic Democrats, just think ātrans woman == man in dress,ā and conclude that our sports performance must be closer to cis men than cis women. Itās just stereotypes and bigotry. Thatās all this is.
And thatās the problem. Because once youāve given into one form of irrational, unscientific bigotry, you have no reason to ever stop. If you wonāt listen to the science when bigots say trans women have an unfair advantage in sports, you wonāt listen to science when bigots say that trans women are a threat in womenās restrooms and locker rooms. If you donāt give a shit about science, youāll have no problem caving to bigots who hand wring about trans kids receiving trans healthcare. Itās completely unscientific and bigoted to let a tiny minuscule regret rate influence your conclusion, but if youāve abandoned science once, youāll do it again.
As a trans person, I honestly do not give two shits about sports. But what I DO care about is the precedent it sets. There has never been a state that passed a trans sports ban through its legislature that then didnāt also go on to persecute trans people in numerous areas of life.
Think more than two seconds into the future.
Remember, Jim Crow was passed because white women didnāt āfeel comfortableā sharing spaces with black women.