Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has accused establishment Democrats of treating her ālike shitā as progressive activists urged her to run for president in 2028.
In a 100-minute long video posted on Instagram, the 37-year-old congresswoman from New York said that the party had a āremarkable opportunityā to pass left-wing policies after the midterm elections. She also accused the partyās leadership of starving funds from left-wing candidates during the campaign.
āThereās this huge conversation about candidates that were under invested in,ā Ocasio-Cortez said. She cited Angie Nixon, a member of the Democratic Socialists of America who came within 240,000 votes of flipping Florida from red to blue, but ultimately lost to the Republican candidate Ashley Moody.
āIf Angie Nixon had just had a little bit of that support, that outcome could have changed. But that money has to come from somewhere and it comes from these people,ā Ocasio-Cortez said in reference to the partyās Senate leadership.
Reflecting on the period after she was first elected to Congress in 2018 at the age of 29, Ocasio-Cortez accused senior Democrats of being āhorrifically cruelā to her. āI mean I was treated like shit,ā she said. āEverybody took a swing at me.ā
The Bronx congresswoman is seen as the likeliest progressive candidate to run for the Democratic nomination for president in 2028.
She 100% has my vote.
I love her, but Congress needs to change its makeup first to be all progressive and pass progressive legislations that will turn successful before she has any chance of presidency.
As of right now if she would run I expect she would lose. I think people want to give progressives a chance but likely would still be hesitant until progressives prove themselves.
Iāve literally heard these sentiments my entire life, and progressives keep proving it wrong every time.
The latest was my dad saying, āwell of course a progressive could win in New York, but not anywhere else in the country.ā
I think the nation has shown multiple times in the past decade that what we really donāt want is another fucking status quo democrat. The country is desperate for change, and if the democrats and people with your sentiment would take their foot off progressivesā necks and stand behind us instead, progressives could actually make this country great (for the first time, btw).
This is exactly why Hillary lost, FWIW. People were tired of establishment dems being in control. They wanted a shakeup. And in response to that, Dems ran the very personification of the establishment. Hillary was the face of everything that people hated about democrats.
As far as the establishment saw it, she had done her time as a good little soldier, paid her dues promptly, sang the partyās songs, danced the partyās dances, and was āowedā the chance at a presidency because of that. Not because she was the best candidate for the people, but because she was the one who best embodied the establishment that Dems wanted to uphold.
Instead, people voted for the candidate who promised exactly what people wanted: A shakeup. Trump wasnāt a good candidate during his first campaign, but he did promise an end to the old status quo. And to a lot of voters, that was the only thing that mattered.
A bit more context on Clinton: The DNC was pretty much broke and their finances were a mess. Clinton came in and cleaned house and raised a bunch of money and basically saved the DNC from total insolvency. In return for saving their asses, her campaign was given a lot of control over the DNC. She had control of finances and hiring and firing.
How did the DNC get in such bad financial shape in the 1st place? Was it just incompetance or was there also fraud? If youāre a high level DNC leader, do you owe Clinton for saving your job or do you owe her for preventing a scandal that could land you in jail?
All this to say, from the outside it looks like āshe put in her time, itās her turnā but from the inside itās more āweāve totally fucked up and if we donāt let her take the wheel we will be jobless, disgraced and possibly sued or jailedā
That Clinton fundraising didnāt save the DNC, it destroyed its soul.
Do you think those millions of dollars of corporate cash came without strings? Of course not. After accepting this money, the DNC was all-in on support for the military industrial complex, wall street, health insurers, etc.
This had horrible effects on DNC policy in the following years- supporting the forever wars, abandoning the public option, bailing out wall street while abandoning working people⦠So many horrible things were set in motion by this Clinton corruption.
Before the Clinton sellout we had one corporate party and one moderate party. After the sellout we only have 2 corporate parties to choose from.
Do you think those millions of dollars of corporate cash came without strings?
No. I do not. And I never said otherwise.
I was not in any way saying that this was a good thing.
Before the Clinton sellout we had one corporate party and one moderate party. After the sellout we only have 2 corporate parties to choose from.
Are you talking about Bill? Cuz the DNC has been all about the donors for a long time. Hillary definitely made it worse (as did citizens united) but theyāve been pretty mid (at best) almost my whole life.
Citizens united was the death of this country
And Hawaii and Montana have shown us how to kill it. If you arenāt in a shit hole red state, you should get busy working on that.
Hillary won the popular vote.
The electoral college screwed you over
Because she campaigned heavily in blue states and neglected the states she actually needed to win. While Iām not a fan of the electoral college, in this case Hillary was intentionally playing the wrong game.
deleted by creator
Bruh, Texas just turned blue. Anything is possible rn.
If you look at the answers to surveys people were providing during voting it looks like top issues were affordability and corruption/concerns about democracy.
Progressives are given a chance and need to deliver on it otherwise they will be treated like trump (remember he promised a lot of that too)
The 2028 might not get the same boost, although I hope it will.
Mamdani has delivered undeniable results, El-Sayed pulled off the impossible and his ideas make sense, not in a Trump way, in a common sense way. Many of these candidates were outspent 20 to one or more and they won, previously thought so unlikely as to be impossible. Bernie and AOCās rallies were packed in every city, compared to Trump having to pay what little people he had at his rallies. The country is ready and any more arguments to the contrary are not in good faith imo.
1/3rd of Democratic voters this election self-identified as democratic socialists. The days when progressive politics were a minor phenomenon are over. Besides, any successful movement needs to keep making swipes at power even if it doesnāt succeed; these moves are part of what legitimizes it and increases its influence.
You expect she would lose because youāre not recognizing the material conditions of the moment.
People want change. People demand change. A progressive president and a supermajority has the potential to do so much good.
And if it doesnāt, the peopleās contradictions will get worse and worse to the point theyāll take matters into their own hands.
Iād expect better from my instance. But then again, people of my instance are all anarchists who want to throw away all governments without considering how this would affect normal, working class people. Yāall have no solution for improving peopleās lives.
Be socialist instead
deleted by creator
They have.
The old guard has helped republicans turn this country into a facist shit hole.
Yes. Theyāre all ratchet democrats who are in it only for the corporate dollars.
Honestly you are being too generous. They want the oligarchy to rule this country, they just disagree with Republicans on how to accomplish that.
They think they should throw some crumbs to working people and pay lip service to democracy so the people donāt oppose the. Too much.
Itās āfascistā, and Republicans did that just fine on their own.
Yeah and 75 house Democrats thanked them for it.
Well that is very very fucked up.
Such is the state of a two party state. No room for distinction. You can be black or you can be white. Aināt that some shit.
Thanks for the spelling correction sweet summer child.
The reddification is complete.
You remind me of Reddit.
Iāll vote for AOC in 2028.
Iām doing it because I believe in her and her policies for improving the material conditions of the working class in USA.
If you canāt bring yourself to vote for her, consider voting AGAINST all of the other stuck up asshats in Congress who think they deserve to have political power.
In 2016, Bernie was looking greatā¦until the DNC happened, he sported a black eye, and then endorsed Hillary for some unknown reason. The establishment Dems are just as corrupt as the Repubs. The only hope for America is in the new bloodā¦because the milkās gone bad.
Trump didnāt win in 2016ā¦Hillary (and DWS) LOST.
AOC should take the House Speaker from Jeffries. Itās where sheās needed most.
AOC as presidential candidate would prove some interesting things about the voting populus, but it would also bring some interesting things to light about the current state of the power the wealthy hold.
The old DNC could try hard to oppose her. But there isnāt a single Democrat with name recognition on her level.
They canāt argue against her policy stance in a way that people would support a competitor.
They could argue against her age and experience, but I think the voting populace doesnāt give a fuck about that anymore. They could result to other personal attacks like her being Puerto Rican, or a woman.
The GOP would result to scare tactics that, apparently, have finally lost their edge.
What Iām curious about isnāt the stuff we see in the news. Trump and the oligarchs would stop at nothing to prevent her victory. The ultra rich never had nearly as much wealth and power as they do now, and a lot of people conveniently died as they became too popular.
Dems exist to stop leftists. They do it over and over.
Thatās a confusing take.
That worked in 2016. That didnāt work in this election. The current DNC chair started his career as an intern working for Paul Wellstone.
Are you suggesting we just do⦠nothing?
We need to harass our reps until they lose the will to live. Be loud, be annoying and most of all be persistent. Tell them what you want clearly, for example, i donāt want schumer and jeffires in leadership positions, so Iām focusing on that. Also give them an alternate path to vote for, like instead of voting for schumer, please vote for Chris Van Hollen. Then do it again the next day. Phone calls preferably.
Just shouting out Joe Neguse as an alternative to Jeffries. He stopped taking aipac money, heās generally progressive, already in leadership in the house, and he is black, so it keeps the implicit promise to the congressional black caucus to elect a black speaker.
Itās not about race, itās about Jeffries.
Iāll look into him, he sounds promising
I fully agree that the next speaker should be Black, but I donāt trust the leadership of the CBC. Jim Clyburn has a lot of bad politics once you look deeper than his civil rights history, and their unwillingness to see the problems with Jeffries are plenty of reason to be concerned with their organization
If you are concerned about Neguse, Ayana Pressley is an alternative. She is progressive and capable. As a spokesperson for āthe squadā I worry that pushing for her would polarise the left right divide and take the focus off the corruption that Jeffries represents.
But by all means. Presley would be far superior to Jeffries. Call her office and urge her to run for speaker against him.
I love Ayanna Pressley and would support her for anything
Iāll do that when my time zone syncs up
Why do you think it didnāt work? A few leftists managed to sneak through, but they succeeded in blocking many more in the primaries.
Who is they?
Democrats, obviously
Be more specific.
The article literally discusses how Democrats helped Florida stay red.
Iād personally rather see her jump to the Senate for a term, or NY Governor, before trying for the presidency. Iād say the same for any House rep. Governors and Senators have the clearest parallels to the office, as executive and foreign-policy roles themselves.
I think AOC is a high-variance candidate - much the same way Trump was in 2016 - and she will either get much more or much less support than expected in the general election.
I think her biggest electoral baggage will be her statements over the years on the āWoke 1.0ā items that the electorate soured on. She has moderated her past statements here more recently, which leaves a lot of doubt as to her actual beliefs and policy goals. Sheāll be attacked for that from the left and the right, and it will take oxygen away from a progressive economic agenda that would likely be broadly popular if explained well.
Whoever the dem candidate ends up being, I doubt they can rely on the same level of support as the party received in the midterms. 2 years is an eternity in politics and 2028 will likely be defined by some new crisis that isnāt even on our radar right now. If she runs, Iāll likely vote for her (at least, based on who else seems to be running as of now).
We simply donāt have time, weāre in need of that once in a generation leader right now and sheās the best weāve got.
There are plenty candidates who could jump in and do a great job. The campaign hasnāt even started yet. I genuinely donāt think jumping from the House to President is a good move, someone needs to hold a higher office first to demonstrate their ability to manage a much larger organization than a House office.
The only person ever elected directly from the House was James Garfield in 1880. Most presidents were previously senators or governors. The only person ever elected without holding any prior office was Donald Trump in 2016.
Jon Ossoff
I have little idea who this is mostly, but I know he came sort of out of nowhere and has been pushed relentlessly in the media, and that make me suspicious. Why him? Why now? Does he have more corporate-friendly moderate-conservative Democratic views that people with money prefer as the alternative? I genuinely donāt know. I really wonder if conservative money interests are scared of AOC and so they are pushing a more moderate Democrat. I donāt know his policies at all though, so maybe I am wrong?
Heās kind of a Sheldon whitehouse type progressive corpo dem. I donāt think he has principles but heās at least better than schumer/Jeffries/pelosi.
We donāt have to settle.
Fully agree!! I was just trying to give the most factual description I could.
Definitely check him out, he got elected the same time as Warnock. Look at his record, watch some of his speeches. Heās great.
Jon Ossof isnāt a progressive; heās a spicy centrist. He voted for the Laken Riley Act and his record on Israel while not wholly bad is way too mixed.
I donāt know as much about him but everything I have seen/heard is promising.
Iād personally rather see her jump to the Senate for a term, or NY Governor, before trying for the presidency. Iād say the same for any House rep. Governors and Senators have the clearest parallels to the office, as executive and foreign-policy roles themselves
only one sitting house rep has been elected president. ONE. garfield, in 1880. a 9-term rep, and at that time he was already chosen by his state legislature to be a senator⦠so like a āsenator electā today⦠which he declined when he won his presidential campaign.
Might I remind you, we elected a twice-impeached, pedophilic reality show star. I think we are well past historical precedents, here.
Yeah I like AOC and would vote for her, but I donāt think 2028 is her year. She has a lot of qualities that each individually could lose support: sheās a woman, non-white, vocally progressive, relatively young, only a Rep, and has a long history of demonization by the right.
None of those traits is particularly damning alone (to the general population, I donāt have a problem with any of it personally), but taken together thatās a lot of hill to climb.
Iād like to see her go for a couple terms in the Senate, which would take care of the ārelatively youngā and āonly a Repā. Plus, hopefully the landscape shifts more progressive which would make her less of an outlier.
I think 47 year old Senator Cortez is a much better bet than 39 year old Representative Cortez, and Iād rather not spoil the former by pushing the latter.
She has a lot of qualities that each individually could lose support: sheās a woman, non-white, vocally progressive, relatively young, only a Rep, and has a long history of demonization by the right.
Thereās simply no evidence that the plausibly Democratic electorate has a problem with any of these. Capturing swing voters is nice but itās not how elections are won.
The primary two Iām focused on are her age and highest office. She is a 37 year old House Representative.
As others have pointed out, only one other President (Garfield) was just a House Representative, and even he was elected to the Senate. And the youngest president ever elected was JFK at 43.
Iām not betting on the youngest, first female, first House Rep. becoming President. Iāll bet on the first female president when sheās not the youngest and has been Senator or Governor.
Maybe the political landscape will radically change over the next year, Iām not opposed to the idea and that would be awesome honestly. But thatās a lot of firsts to tackle, especially when fascism is so pungent in the air.
Put out a 45+ white male progressive for a term or two, lay some groundwork, and then hitāem with Senator Cortezās campaign.
I feel like she could win anyway. Sheās just a natural star politician. Itās a mix of things: the model looks, the clear explanation of policy, the fact that she is relatable in a way so many are not. I think sheād easily win. I think sheād even do okay with the racists⦠sheās just that likable. Why not have 2028 be her year? If not 2028, when? Thereās always a reason among corporate elite conservative Democrats to avoid someone too helpful to the poor and middle class, isnāt there?
I donāt disagree with her positives, I just think sheās on the young side to win in 2028.
I think sheād even do okay with the racists⦠sheās just that likable.
I think you underestimate how much the right wing media has demonized her. I like her, you like her, but a lot of people think sheās a dumb waitress.
Why not have 2028 be her year? If not 2028, when?
2036, after a stint in the Senate. Sheāll be older, sheāll have experience in the Upper House, itās just a much better position for a win.
Thereās always a reason among corporate elite conservative Democrats to avoid someone too helpful to the poor and middle class, isnāt there?
This isnāt about corporate Democrats, this is about progressives acting strategically. I think it would be much better to run an established progressive Senator or Governor in 2028.
I think you underestimate how much the right wing media has demonized her. I like her, you like her, but a lot of people think sheās a dumb waitress.
Give her the podium to debate a Republican on national TV. No one will think that anymore. Itās easily dealt with, even an advantage. They donāt know her yet, so Republicans think many USA Americans hate her. But she is great, middle America just doesnāt know yet.
I disagree. Yes, I like her, but youāre extremely optimistic about how middle America will react. I fear that your perception is biased by surrounding yourself with progressives, not that I blame you. I implore you to spend more time talking to āaverageā Americans. A very large number donāt respect her, and think sheās not even qualified for the House. Never mind her credentials, they think sheās a dumb commie waitress.
Many people are going to think that no matter what. I wish it were otherwise, but people talk to me about their political views. She is a very controversial figure. This isnāt speculation, this is talking to actual people about what they believe.
I want her to run, and I want her to win. And the last thing I want is for her to jump the gun on an early run and ruin her future chances. I wouldāve liked to see Walz run, but the Harris campaign is an albatross around his neck. I do not want her to suffer the same fate, I want her to actually win when she runs.
Again, she would be 39 in '28. Thatās four years younger than JFK, the youngest person ever elected President. Thatās going to be too young for a lot of people.
We already tried this with Bernie Sanders, the peopleās vote donāt matter because the corporations are in danger
Previous losses should not stop us from trying again. The public is shifting. The scenarios are changing in each election cycle.
The public shifted because gas hit $6/gal. I donāt disagree that class consciousness is growing, but I donāt think itās as prevalent in the real world as it is online. And more importantly, I donāt think the party apparatus of the DNC is remotely ready to hand over power to the progressive wing. They will use their oligarchsā money to promote right wingers like Newsom.
All valid points. Although I think conservatives are the ones who are only upset by the gas prices. I suspect the rest of the normally disengaged public may have become engaged in the midterms for the litany of other good reasons as well.
Conservatives obviously canāt change, but my hope is that the normal people will continue to become more and more upset during the remaining time Trump has in office.
By November 2028, if we stay on this course, we might be primed for another dramatic shift left which could affect some components of DNC leadership.
Ejecting conservatives from DNC leadership is the real test, in my opinion.
I like your hope and I want to agree with it, but I also am wary of assuming that normal people are even as aware of news and politics as much as we would hope, let alone care enough about it to do something. I know I live in a bubble of people who care, and Lemmy obviously is its own very specific bubble. I donāt want to take for granted that the majority of people align with my worldview.
Your fears are valid. My fear has subsided slightly because of the midterms. My hope comes from focusing on the next two years only right now.
Beyond that, I worry for the long-term that we may be unable to make extreme reforms: removing money from politics, ending gerrymandering, reforming SCOTUS, dissolving billionaire control of media, etc.
It all seems overwhelming and unlikely. But an overwhelming progressive push for long enough is exactly what it would take to accomplish it.
They didnāt lose the midterms only on gas prices.
The graph of rise in gas prices maps almost perfectly with lost support for the Republicans.
Those two graphs map like 1:1
I agree with you. Things donāt always have nuance and sometimes correlation does equal causation. There was lots of stuff going on, but that was the main thing.
And that is one sad motherfucking state of affairs.
I actually tried to find the stat for you, because I saw it on a dependable news channel and it shocked me because it was like 1:1.
Let me see if I can get Jamie to pull that up for me, hey Jamie!
Itās not the only thing that voters were mad about, but it didnāt help Republicans, thatās for sure.
For sure.
Agreed, there were many things that influenced people in a variety of ways, but cost of living is the one big thing that impacts everybody.
I donāt get the hate for Newsom. From what Iāve seen heās doing a good job.
Heās a standard corporate Dem that looks out for oligarchs before working people. He recently opposed the ballot measure that would have put a one-time wealth tax on billionaires.
He threw trans people under the bus.
And everyone not in the 0.1%
Not to minimize what he did to us, but to show heās not only problematic for trans people.
True, true. It was just the first issue that came to mind.
I mean thatās the same single issue shit that the Republicans do with the 2A. Whatās the difference? āHeās not 100% perfect, therefore I will refuse to vote for him and let Republicans take a seat that will for sure be worse for my causeā
Itās Palestine all over again
How? How did he do that exactly?
Fighting against a billionaireās tax, hating on trans people, and sleeping with your best friendās wife? Count me out! If heās the candidate, I wouldnāt vote for him.
Listen, I only know what I know from what I see from abroad. Could you provide some links or verification for what you say? Because I read a lot of US news, but itās a bit much to keep track of, so, for me, from what Iāve read in actual articles, Iāve been on his side for a lot of the more controversial topics, because heās had some 50/50 decisions, like that one thing with transā¦
So the bill was like, you allow gender affirming care AND allow other states to extradite citizens from California from seeking GAC in Ca if they come there specifically for that reason.
Which is extremely fucked up. Itās pork barrelling, as far as I see it, and I think Newsom catches a lot of flak from the queer crowd even though his decisions protect them from nazi state interferenceā¦
Iād love to hear your thoughts on that.
What? Really? That allowed other states to extradite those in the state specifically for GAC?
He is fighting against the billionaire tax.
How is he doing that? You got a bill or something he voted against? Because I hear a lot of criticism but not a lot of sources.
Please donāt āgoogle it broā me, please. I want to know exactly what you guys have a problem with and I have for some time and I never hear anything concrete.
Please mind, Iām not from the USA, I try to keep up as best I can, but from my point of view he has some pretty sensible politics.
Here is the first google result of Gavin Newsom billionaire tax.
He is a snake that adopts progressive policies when it suits him, then drops them when the political winds shift if when they threaten capital. He opposed the cali wealth tax. Hes thrown trans kids under the bus retorically.
Newsom has done good things. He was the mayor of San fransisco in like 2002 that issued marriage licenses to gay couples before it was popular or even legal. But he is not our friend and he doesnāt seem to have principled beliefs, just political instincts.
Who is āusā? Friend of whom? Weāre not a monolith.
And I hear what youāre saying, but itās all hearsay to me. Iāve watched his politicking and heās fighting the good fight, I think. And Iām afraid people are so hypersensitive now that they will interpret anything he does as anti-āthemā and just refuse to vote, giving the republicans a very easy fight because nobody is voting.
Thatās the plight of a two party state. But if you have something you think particularly he did wrong or was unforgivable, give me the source and I will read up on it and see what itās about, because I have so far, and I can see what is maneuver and what is a semblance of idealism.
Newsom is better than any Republican, and itās not close. There is always a better and worse decision. My critiques of Newsom are about his character relative to other options in the party.
deleted by creator
These midterms just proved that numbers are more important than money. Itās not just āpossibleā to outvote corporate candidates, it should be considered an obligation.
So we should just do nothing
I really donāt want her to run for president yet. Iād rather see her replace schumer first. She is my congresswoman too and am very happy with her. I just fear she might not win presidency yet. Our district is very left wing, so I need to know she can win in a place like New York State that is kind of a microcosm of the whole country
I remember Pelosi especially was vicious. AOC didnāt get brave again for a year + after that shit. Great point about Angie, she would have won with minimal support. We need to form a 3rd party, enough is enough.
How about taking over the Democratic Party? That process is already underway, letās keep it going
Nah, take over the Democratic party from the inside. Like the tea party did, which paved the way for maga inside the Republican party. Without first fixing our voting system, third parties do nothing but harm
The tea party did that with the blessing and funding of oligarchs. Leftists donāt have oligarch funding.
Did that stop leftists from taking power on November 3rd?
The people outweigh the money, as long as we are organized.
I agree with you in principle, but the tea party was an astroturf movement so a very different situation. A progressive takeover of the Democratic party could get much more ugly. That majority the Dems now enjoy, includes DINOs like Fetterman, and centrist/establishment types like Schumer and Pelosi. They are facing an existential threat to their kind of politics (the kind where you sell your soul to corporate donors and AIPAC). If push comes to shove, I wouldnāt be surprised if they side with the GOP, choosing to scupper the Democratic party rather than work with a progressive agenda.
I want it to happen, just donāt expect it will happen without a hard and dirty fight. The powers behind the political establishment do NOT want this.
We need to form a 3rd party, enough is enough.
āHow Republicans Never Lost an Election Again: The Realities of Vote-Splittingā
Might I suggest the Working Families Party instead of forming a new one? Just make sure to take into account the realities of FPtP voting, if your district hasnāt implemented a better system.
Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) as well
The Democratic Socialists of America are seeing a surge in political power over the last few election cycles. The DSA alone now has over 130,000 active, dues paying members.
Why the fuck should we throw that all away now?
We can take over the Democratic party, and in doing so, push the Right-wing Democrats to the Republican party and eliminate the current GOP altogether. There is a future where we permanently shift the Overton Window left.
Yāall want to kneecap progress when we havenāt even gotten started yet.
Her honesty and directness are so refreshing. I wish I could be more like her, just a totally good pure person. It also seems like she genuinely tries hard, like her success is not without extreme effort.
Itās a choice, she chooses that path, every time. Repeatedly, regardless of what she faces, she tries to make the best choices in that situation. And the more you do that the better you get at it. It sounds simple, in writing it out, but itās usually the hardest choice. Itās choosing to stick to your guns, regardless of social ostracism.
Repeatedly, regardless of what she faces, she tries to make the best choices in that situation
Including voting against the bill to discontinue funding for the Zionazi stateās Iron Dome?
(Edit: My mistake, she actually voted "Presentā, and her excuse was basically āthe bill didnāt do enough so I decided we should do nothing at allā. Very Democrat of her indeed.)
It was chess. She sent a long letter to her constituents explaining why she went from no to present.
There was a lot on the table they were fighting for in a republican led congress.
Dems pressured her hard to vote yes, and she needed them to synchronize to try to rescue āThe Build Back Better packageā
The bill was rushed in to create a political wedge
finally her vote was not actually affecing the outcome, so it was pure political capitalI donāt give a fuck about your āchessā during genocide. You vote to stop the mass ethnic cleansing of human beings or you donāt. And if you donāt, fuck you, in the least uncertain of terms.
How often have you been in a position where you had to chose between results and principles?
Politicians who stand unflinchingly on their convictions do not serve the people. You will never hear the voices of those who fell on their swords to avoid going against their morals, for they are dead and their swords are buried in what could have been our ally.
The results Iām interested in achieving basically never conflict with my principles, so no occasions immediately come to mind.
If you donāt unflinchingly stand against genocide, you are a waste of a human, politician or otherwise.
What does it mean to unflinchingly stand against genocide? Is your opinion that when given the trolly problem the correct answer is scream at the trolly that it isnāt supposed to kill people? Does that fix the problem.
Be careful with your conviction without decision as it is more likely to be taken advantage of than to ever help you or others. āOnly a Sith deals in absolutes.ā - Apparently a Sith Obi-Wan Kenobi
Well lookie here, another fine blocked user, good riddance
liberals when they encounter principles: BLOCKED
No concessions on Genocide support.
good for you, nothing to see here
People pointed out that any financial support frees up budgets for offensive weapons and she changed her stance. (Or maybe it was the backlash in general.) I donāt know what votes have come up since.
No such a thing as a ātotally good pure personā. You can praise people without lying to yourself, itās possible I promise . She deserves more intellectually honest praise than āsheās perfect and without flawā
āPureā is nonexistent drivel. No human is āpureā anything. Its dehumanizing. Sheās human. Sheās imperfect. She gets the job done and has a good heart. Sheās not pure in anything.
I donāt knowā¦itās hard to think Stephen Miller isnāt pure hobbit Nosferatu.
Her honesty, directness, and willingness to continue using our taxpayer dollars to continue funding ādefensiveā weapons for an apartheid occupation determined by the UN to be guilty of genocide.
(Edit: My mistake, she actually voted "Presentā, and her excuse was basically āthe bill didnāt do enough so I decided we should do nothing at allā. Very Democrat of her indeed.)
I will vote for her in the primary and happily the general election if she wins the primary. I certainly hope she does.
Iād consider voting for her in the general even if she lost the primary.
If only we had ranked choice voting nationwide
Itās as obvious to them as it is to us. It would be naive to think they donāt know. At this point everyone against RCV is telling us who they really support by their actions.
AOC supports ranked choice voting and thatās why sheāll likely get my vote.
If sheās the democratic candidate then democrats are dummer then I thought. Itās been proven the US will not vote in a women president. Boomers wonāt, Muslims wonāt, orthodox Jewish wonāt. Uber religious Catholics wonāt. Just too much change at once will ruin the it for her. 10:years from now maybe.
Clinton won the popular vote in 2016. We have had a decade since then. I think you are also way over-generalizing the groups you mention.
Last time I checked we still have the electoral college. I should have used that example as well as to why a female president wonāt happen yet. I say 10 years as thatās when many older boomers will be dead. A see of change will happen in Washington as millennials step up to the plate to control the white house
I would say itās been proven that Democrats, mostly progressives, wonāt vote for a candidate who spouts conservative values. Which is what both Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris did. For fuckās sake Kamala Harris graciously accepted the endorsement by fucking Dick Cheney and his piece of shit daughter. Literally the moment she did that I knew we lost the race.
you have no idea what youāre talking about, so you should stop.
I have a pretty good idea what Iām talking about
obviously, you think you do.
you donāt.
Well in a couple years weāll see wonāt we. Frankly I hope I am wrong. But Iāve seen this before and how it ends.
go ahead and message me in a couple years.
also, you spelled dumber wrong.
Yes, he does. He is correct, too many people (even those on āthe leftā) donāt seem to come out to vote when a woman is the candidate, not for president at least.
AOC is far far more popular than Hilary ever was. The problem isnāt the voters.
Well, no. The problem is literally the voters, because they keep failing to vote for women to be president.
More people voted for Hillary Clinton than Trump.
Yeah but we have an electoral college so that doesnāt matter and many of the small rural states arenāt the voting women type
The Democrats now control enough state legislatures that they can do away with the Electoral Collage via the NPVIC.
Fingers crossed
This is huge, and needs to be a major discussion in America.
I have a feeling we are going to have to hold their feet to the fire to force them to do the right thing.
Sure. My point is that the plurality of voters would vote in a woman, and tried to.
Iām not saying itās more likely than not, but something like the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is possible.
So, the US as a people would vote in a woman but our antidemocratic political system fucks it up.
Yeah, I also said in another comment that it will happen eventually, just not this next election
This is unfortunately very true, have my upvote.
A 100 minute video from AOC? Iād love to watch it, why would she only post it to Instagram? Are there any mirrors out there?
^ yes. Elected officials speaking about elected stuff should never post to closed platforms only.
Why in the hell twitter was ever used for emergency management / communication, particularly exclusively, was a mystery to me
āExclusivelyā is def a problem, but it makes perfect sense to put important stuff where the people are.
She meets people where they are. People are, unfortunately, on instagram
She should post her stuff on lemmy. All 15 of us would be so happy and informed
Not all people. I want to watch the video, but not bad enough to make an Instagram account.
Found a mirror: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OFqWmoyDN1s
I remember her speaking about this quite candidly not too long ago (I want to say last year or two but time flies these days) about going into a side room off the House chamber and seeing herself giving an interview on a major outlet, and a fellow Democrat ā knowing she was there ā just shaking his head at the TV.
That cruelty exemplifies what is wrong with the party, and precisely why the likes of Schumer and Jeffries must go.
She needs to overhaul the party. I kind of lean toward her primarying Schumer, but I am amicable to a 2028 run. Whichever she decides, Iām with her.
If she doesnāt, the best compromise I can see that can viably win is probably Ossoff, which given what he said here I think is generally the right message to carry forward.
Edit: I do think itās worth pointing out that she of course wouldnāt even be viable under the Republican ticket. That like Sanders, she chooses to caucus with Democrats for good reason. Perfect? No. Better? Undeniably so. On every single issue, frankly.
That said, the 2028 Democratic Primaries are officially on, and itās time to make Democrats a little more perfect.
Their unabashed support for Israel, including AOCās decision to vote against discontinuing Iron Dome funding (in other words, if you remove the double-negative, voting to continue funding it), seems like a bit more apt exemplification of āwhat is wrong with the partyā than someone shaking their head at a TV.
Sheās part of the problem. Ilhan Omar is a much stronger example.
(Edit: My mistake, she actually voted "Presentā, and her excuse was basically āthe bill didnāt do enough so I decided we should do nothing at allā. Very Democrat of her indeed.)
I have no problem with AOCās ethical stance ā mirroring that of El-Sayedās recent words himself noting protecting all children, including Israeli children. The needle can be threaded, and I condemn just as much those child deaths on O7 as I do the greater atrocity by Israel that came after, proportionally. Only the humane would.
Additionally AOC would later state that Israel can fund its own defensive systems and refused to further provide such aid. Presumably this is in part due to the risk of Israel misappropriating these resources as well.
Overall AOC rarely misses the mark, and Iām no single-issue voter. Climate Change, Womenās Rights, LGBTQ+ rights, Healthcare, Support for Ukraine against the Ruzzian genocide, Campaign Finance / Election Reform, protection for immigrants, etc. ā there is a lot to consider, and even within the framework of Palestinian human rights, we wouldnāt have a problem standing up to Israel if every person in Congress was like her.
We need to remind ourselves too that Democrats are better for civilians than Republicans in every way and end more wars than they start, at least in the past 30 or so years. For example, Trump with Muskās help gutted USAID, which has now led to over 600,000 civilians deaths in just a yearās time, and continuously rising. That dwarfs the deaths in Gaza and Ukraine, combined. Naturally one atrocity does not detract from another, but itās important to put into context the Greater Evil in what is often an inevitably binary-choice outcome for elections. In other words, never let perfect be the enemy of better.
First, given the technological and military gap, Israeli children are under no threat at all compared to Palestinian children. And second, calling for the dismantling of Israel and the creation of a multi-ethnic democratic Palestine would do more to protect all children than giving Israel the means to continue their genocide. Israel, as a settler colonial project, invites violent resistance against itself. Israeli would be more safe if the Israeli state didnāt exist.
mirroring that of El-Sayedās recent words himself noting protecting all children, including Israeli children
The existence of israel guarantees the continued death of Palestinian children. You donāt get to have your cake and eat it too.
The rest of your points are fair but I donāt trust her. I donāt trust any Democrat (or other politician) unconditionally, but Ilhan Omar is by far in the lead for me. I hope Iām wrong about AOC but that vote tells me sheās more of a political opportunist than a truly principled person - and changing when the winds blow differently could support that conclusion just as much as it could support the conclusion that she saw the error of her ways.
For example, Trump with Muskās help gutted USAID, which has now led to over 600,000 civilians deaths in just a yearās time, and continuously rising. That dwarfs the deaths in Gaza and Ukraine, combined. Naturally one atrocity does not detract from another, but itās important to put into context the Greater Evil in what is often an inevitably binary-choice outcome for elections.
Right, but the weak leadership of the Democrats (and their corruption in rigging the primaries against their populist uprising in the form of Bernie Sanders) enabled Trumpās rise. So itās binary in the narrative, but under an oligarchy, itās really just one choice (so no choice) with different theatrical performances attached.
I think my opinion of Israel and its future existence as a state is independent of Hamas murdering children ā regardless of nationality. Iām fairly sure El-Sayed would say something similar.
I do greatly appreciate Ilhan Omar as well, donāt get me wrong! Sheās just not in a position to challenge Schumer.
Right, but the weak leadership of the Democrats (and their corruption in rigging the primaries against their populist uprising in the form of Bernie Sanders) enabled Trumpās rise. So itās binary in the narrative, but under an oligarchy, itās really just one choice (so no choice) with different theatrical performances attached.
But thatās not the opinion of the very guy for whom they allegedly rigged against, is it?
By all means, I think we have our work cut out for us to clean Democrats up, but the likes of Bernieās acolyte, AOC, is by no means the problem. Very low if not next to last on the totem pole.
Also I donāt find it performative when we know if Harris won, 600,000 people would be alive who now are not. When weād still be in the JCPOA and not have bombed an Iranian school and more. When weād still be in the WHO. When weād still be in the Paris Climate Agreement.
Iām not sure what you mean by the first line. My meaning is you donāt get to frame enabling Israelās continued existence via funding for the Iron Dome as being about some sort of net-effect of protecting children when Israelās mere existence guarantees the opposite, as demonstrated again and again throughout history.
Indeed, Bernieās movement outgrew him, starting from the day he caved and endorsed Biden. And look what that got us: I was duped into voting for genocide, in the name of ālesser evilā politics. That paradigm is how we ended up in a world where the ālesser evilā is āmaybe theyād do a little less genocide than the other guy.ā
Harris promised the āmost lethal fighting force in the history of the worldā or whatever the quote was, and promised āno deviationā from Bidenās openly-genocidal policies. You can dream of a kinder genocidaire, Iāll dream of the end of genocide and empire.
Well I think the cart is being put before the horse; for we must deal with the present reality instead of far-fetched idealism: Israel exists, and that fact isnāt changing anytime soon. If we want to talk about net data: then providing defensive missiles so errant rockets donāt strike civilians isnāt necessarily a bad thing because ultimately a net-reduction of child deaths occur. The absence of funding for the Iron Dome further yields no evidence as to the damage wrought by Israel (e.g., Iranian and Hamas missiles have in no way shape or form deterred Israel from carrying out its offensive strikes of genocide).
It just leads to a net-increase in civilian deaths, overall.
When each childās life is sacred, I can see why one would advocate to mitigate all. Either way, I suppose this is water under the bridge considering AOCās position has since shifted anyway and sheās still better than any Republican ā which is why every single true dissenter to the war caucuses with Democrats, at least while in elected office. A few Republicans protest, but mostly from the sidelines and having since been primaried out.
Not sure what you mean with respect to Sanders; for independent of the movement outgrowing Bernie, you do see why Bernie continues to caucus and endorse Democratic candidates under the same principle of ālesser evilā politics? Why the man himself does try to play the game of sitting out of elections or partaking accelerationism? Why Ilhan Omar does the same. Even Ilhan Omar endorsed Harris, rightfully so. So how can they be both sides of the same coin when one side is simply better than the other on practically every issue, including Gaza, USAID, and Ukrainian support?
Some of your quotes from Harris are anachronistic. She went further, called for Palestinian self-determination, ceasefire, and two-state solution. In order to deal with the greater evil of Trump, she had to toe the line on battleground swing states with considerable populations of Jewish supporters who at the time were still somewhat sympathetic to Israel (we all saw what happened to Cori Bush). She got scared, tried to play safe by listening to advisors. In spite of this she was still better (again, see Sanders and Omarās endorsement).
But the ethical stance you have of āprotecting all childrenā is itself the far-fetched idealism you admit weāre not in a position to deal with, given that we canāt really stop Israel from bombing Palestinian children (as itās proven to do perpetually) as long as itās recognized as a sovereign state.
Disagree with the starting premise. Rhodesia existed. Then it didnāt. Israel must meet the same end.
I have no problem with AOCās ethical stance ā mirroring that of El-Sayedās recent words himself noting protecting all children, including Israeli children.
Problem: The less resources Israel has to spend on its own defense the more it can spend on offense. Maybe Israel wouldnāt keep oppressing Palestinians if it didnāt have the wealthiest countries in the world protecting it from the resulting blowback. Itās not pretty but the math is clear: Any funding or support at all for the IDF enables it to kill more Palestinians.
Jon āLaken Riley Actā Ossoff is a moderate dem borrowing economic populist language to win. I donāt trust him
That will indeed be very damaging to his campaign. If not him, who?
Personally, Iām fully invested in AOC. Iāll have to evaluate each person in the primary if she doesnāt run, but Iām not interested in pre-negotiating a shift to the center for the Dem nomination.
āā¦Anyway, thatās why Iām excited to give Hakeem Jefferies my full and unconditioned support.ā
(Did the article mention this? Itās paywalled for me.)
I can defend that. Jeffries is a nonentity; house democrats have been able to walk past him for 2 years. Schumer is far more of a problem, and has the contacts and connections to ratfuck anyone over anything. When Schumer wants to raise money and whip for Israel, he opens his Rolodex. When Jeffries wants to raise money and whip for Israel, he asks Schumer to open his Rolodex. Both need to go, but ousting Schumer as majority leader is step 1 towards that. You can disagree with the political calculus on that, but there is political calculus on that.
Iām not a parliamentary expert, but that doesnāt sound correct to me.
Doesnāt the speaker control who chairs each committee and what legislation makes it to the floor?
As speaker, Jeffries can ā and will ā put allies as chairs of committees to make sure that Medicare for All never gets out of committee. He could single-handedly prevent a vote to abolish ICE from taking place, even if a majority were in support. The speaker is third in line of succession to the presidency, and is arguably the most powerful position in the federal government after the President.
I donāt think your characterization matches reality at all.
Just wanted to swoop back after recent revealings by an incoming house member: Fuck Jeffries. The other person who replied to you was right about what I meant, but, it is very disheartening to see⦠Like obviously the establishment will bully people to support Jeffries. But itās disheartening to see AOC among the people that tactic is successful on.
Fwiw, I have a theory about AOC: I admit, I was way into her cult of personality a few years ago, and I know a lot of people either still are or have snapped the other way.
I think on January 6th she got a big taste of what being a Malcolm X or a Che Guevara really means. Sheās talked about getting trapped in the capital in Katie Porterās office, and I think after surviving what she expected was her own assassination by a fascist mob at 30 she realized that she wasnāt really as down with the revolutionary life as she thought.
Which I can forgive. I donāt blame her. Sheās not the cold-blooded badass weād hoped for, and thatās okay.
Sheās a good member of congress, but weāre going to have to look elsewhere for the future leader we thought she might be.
I think he is not talking about what the speaker can do, but what sort of person Jeffries is personally. I can kind of see it, he interviews kind of like phone tree. So if he āleadsā like that then he may be a fairly mundane pass through for whatever most folks are going with. Others can and have meddled a lot, but he may just be background character enough to insert much of anything specific to the role.
But not crazy about the concept of a guy that I donāt think can think on his feet in being in such a high visibility role either way.
Did she say the bad treatment ended? Sheās probably getting bullied to support him like everyone else.
Youāre a tough woman! Fight back.
Thatās quite literally what sheās doing - sheās planning on running for president despite the horrible treatment.
We donāt have enough of her to go around. We also need her to take one of the New York Senate seats. Itās weird how leadership is not only Zionist but also made up of a significant number of people from the New York metro area.
Mamdani is seeding enough people that can jump into that Senate race if AOC runs for president.
For instance I still contend the long play is to have Brad Lander run for Schumerās seat
And depending on his ambitions I could see Mamdani running for governor of NY in 2030 and one of the NYC DSA reps challenging Gillibrand.
I would vote for Mamdani so hard for governor.
Itās not weird at all, and doesnāt even require conspiracy. Social clubs, sports clubs, religious sites, and schools.
The way the craven privileged bond and form their cliques, and how easy they are to influence during their early stages of teenage āI know everythingā, spoiled rich brat version, are neither imaginative nor mysterious.
No matter how badly the chuds try to give their group chats cool names, theyāre always either impressionable fucks trying to outrun daddyās legacy to make their own, or already compromised by generational favor debts.
The most insulting part of Israelās puppet up the ass of the worldās wealthy white men, is how fucking embarrassingly easy it was to size the fit.
Why do you think all the pro Zionist arguments (or defenses) right now are emotion based? The most common example is āwe donāt feel safe without Israelā followed by āobjecting to Zionism or Israel is anti-Semitic!ā
When I see these people arguing for Israel I just think, āwow, youāre really unhinged and havenāt addressed the argument being brought forthā
Why do I think? The same reason every other issue that is not at all divisive in the face of decency is currently an emotional game of feelings over reality: Itās the easiest form of divide and conquer to effect the manipulation over the largest amount of people, which also provides the required length of cognitive dissonance to meet whatever selfish goal the pricks are using it for with very little upkeep after priming.
The rest of the pieces to make it stick are repeated ad nauseam on Lemmy by many comrades, many whom I would say I vehemently disagree on further finer points, but thatās the crux of it.
Capitalism is not human, and it does not lend itself to engendering human responses to human problems.
Iām so tired of hearing people use āunhingedā. Itās like one day some kid on the schoolyard said it during recess and now the whole fucking school is using it for everything constantly.
Someone who uses āAnn Archyā as their handle is complaining about the word āunhingedā being infantileā¦
sick burn breh!
Feel free to substitute any of the following: Deranged, demented, psychotic, disturbed, unstable, unbalanced
She did, but it took her over a year to shake off how they treated her, especially Pelosi.
āPrOgResSiVe AcTiViStSā
You mean to say the people who are trying to keep democracy from falling? Or the ones who are trying to keep a roof over their head and food on the table?
Stfu already.



















