As he teases a 2028 presidential bid, US Rep. Ro Khanna is reigniting the healthcare debate that was front and center during the last open Democratic presidential primary and making the case for Medicare for All.
The California Democrat responded Monday to a common talking point from opponents of a single-payer healthcare program: that it would force those who want to keep their current insurance plans to give them up for a one-size-fits-all public plan.
āMedicare for All means healthcare for everyone, like public school is free for every kid,ā Khanna wrote on social media. āPrivate insurance can still exist on top of it, just like private school still exists.ā
The Medicare for All bills introduced in the House and Senate by Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) would cover virtually all medically necessary healthcare, including doctor visits, hospital stays, prescription drugs, dental and vision care, and long-term care.
My elderly mother is a lifelong conservative, and when she found out the school my kids go to had free breakfast and lunch she was appalled. So I asked her āshould the school charge for books and gas mileage for the buses?ā To which she of course replied no. How did we get this way? Why is wanting to provide basic services a radical idea?
Honestly itās because of racism and classism, because God forbid someone who they feel is lower than them have something that they donāt think they should have.
We have been systematically de-educated as a deliberate plan by the wealthy to roll back all of the protections implemented through the New Deal and Great Society reforms.
Conservatives have a hard time with object permanence. They truly have difficulty understanding that the taxes they pay get used for societal benefits. It should be easy to see that the money used to fix roads and pay for school books come from tax dollars weāve put into the system, but conservatives just think these things happen for free.
Itās why they have such difficulty supporting Universal Healthcare. āHow will we afford it? Thereās no money for free healthcare!ā Conservative voters being duped canāt connect the dots that the money they currently, already spend on private healthcare could instead be spent on universal healthcare for a cheaper cost and better results. Tax money has been made into a nebulous concept to conservatives as money that should not benefit the common person.
Seems to be right around 1863/1865 and then reinforced during 1965.
Change is scary
Personally I actually am torn on if private health insurance should be permitted. But I also feel that way about private schools despite being glad I attended them
Weāll never get M4A approved unless private insurance exists in some form š I hate it but itās a compromise Iām willing to make
They should be allowed in a free market. The market would inevitably reject them if there was a real public option, and they would die or be so unprofitable that only a few would exist with specific use cases. In my opinion.
Why not invest more in public schools so we donāt need private ones?
I wish we had federal-level schools, with state-specific curricula
But then how will we keep the poors poor?
Yes, and Iām all for it and there are models to use that work great. Think of it like infrastructure and other public goods like parks, libraries, fire dept, city maintenance, etc. It costs less without the insurance profit waste in the middle, spreading cost and risk the most possible and no more medical debt and bankruptcies. No more of that or losing care when the owners decide to lay off people in the next recession, or for changes they make and you become obsolete.
Real freedom is not tied to certain jobs for āgood insuranceā, itās when you can leave it to find a better job you like more, to care for family or even start your own business. Itās proven in many other places and even states with expanded Medicaid health improved too. The owners like this leverage they have, and universal healthcare takes it away from them, reduces the artificial scarcity they want as much as possible. Learn more here: duck.ai/share/a579cb9e-36df-4b50-a1a1-c47498cdd835#eF_z6Jw2DwuiZRaclHpZicePUwUYN0HkaTviZlVJIzI
My only worry is that when maga wins and sabotages it like they do to public programs to make them fail, so people dislike them and push them back to the profit models the owners want. They want people desperate and poor and to fill the profit prisons, more than anywhere in the world. So much for freedom womp womp.
Medicare for all means healthcare for everyone
X is equivalent to X? Wow! How insightful. /s
Now letās see if he actually works to pass it instead of telling us it is itself.
āPrivate insurance can still exist on top of it, just like private school still exists.ā
Not the perfect analogy, considering private schools are a net loss for everyone in society, except the few that can afford them.
The sole concept of a private school is nothing but a testimony to the fact that the education system is completely broken. The only reason [wealthy] people ever become interested in private schools is because theyāre seriously dissatisfied with the public ones.
If you look at the countries with the best education systems, youāll notice that all or nearly all of them either forbid the existence of private schools entirely, or regulate them so hard nobody wants to start one.
If rich people canāt pay for their kids to get better, private education, they become incentivized to ensure public education is as good as possible. Thatās exactly what happened in developed countries.
Same goes for private healthcare, but I guess weāre not ready for that discussion. I donāt know if weāll ever be under capitalism.
I mean, in that case, it is kinda the perfect analogy because if we get universal healthcare, private healthcare will try the same things as private education to take money from public coffers.
private schools are a net loss for everyone in society
Not at all. Private schools are great for society, right up until they steal money from public schools. Who cares if someone pays for a private school on top of paying their taxes to fund public schools?
Itās the whole āvoucherā and āchoiceā ideas that are the problem for everyone. Thatās when a few are stealing from society
Some teachers and some doctors still want to be paid. Under a socialized system, the pay needs to be shit because taxpayers foot the bill and you canāt just bill 20k for a routine surgery or 100k for a year of school.
Until we have wages and taxes, thereās going to be demand for better paying jobs and higher quality services and private is where they meet. Once we can get rid of both wages and taxes and just force everyone to do whatever job we need them to do, thereās no need or even possibility for private practices or private schools.
Untrue. Because the public is the ones who says how shit should operate and if we say that doctor should get paid well thatās what it should be
Teachers and doctors are already known for having poor working conditions, yet people still become enter these professions. We do not need to force people to become teachers and doctors, we simply need to remove the obstacles and difficulties that are not inherent to the profession.
The private sector is a big reason why these fields experience outsized difficulties. Privatization has been destroying and sabotaging the public sector for decades in an effort to gain full control over essential sectors of society. A great example of this is the Post Office. The private sector has been doing their best to destroy the USPS, doing stuff like preventing the USPS from being government funded. Isnāt that insane? A government apparatus that is essential to society is not funded by the government? There is a shit ton of these kinds of whack-ass decisions made about USPS that are intentionally designed to worsen and eventually destroy this public service.
There is no proof that the private sector provides higher quality products/services. Private healthcare is more expensive and has worse outcomes, which is why most developed countries provide socialized healthcare. Private education has been a disaster in the US, with graduates often being extremely behind their peers needing extra time and resources to catch up to where they should be.
Thereās still supply and demand. If physicians are no longer paid enough, we should expect fewer until they do. The real problem is politicians arenāt able to look ahead far enough to keep the pipeline filled
Realistically arenāt we already there? As we depend more on urgent care, those physicians are likely paid a lot less. As we get more PAs and RNs take over healthcare formerly done by physicians, providers are paid less
We are
one ofthe only developed country that doesnāt have it.Lots of developing countries have it too
We pay for Israel to have it.
Itās a fucking political suicide to be even campaigning to abolish affordable healthcare in the rest of the world! So, many conservative politicians stealthily try to do it by underfunding public health services, claim it doesnāt work, and use the manufactured crisis to privatise healthcare.
America, from first world to third world in under two generations!
And no public option, this is a false choice that creates a loophole in the system that will cause it to collapse.
Basically public option would keep the existing insurance companies and push the stickiest people there. The PO would not have a good way to negotiate prices, it would have rising premiums (due to most members being sick). Depending on actions it would take it might even lose doctors.
We need Medicare for all. Insurances are free to provide additional coverage on top of that.
Insurance companies must be mandated to be non profit, and barred from operating point of care services, owning stake in any healthcare related organizations, and have their salaries set and all forms of compensation require Congressional approval.
Their job is to allow people to access care, nothing else.
If people want insurance, fine. But insurance exists to make the system worse, and in areas where itās available public healthcare suffers as a result.
Everyone in the same pool means we all care about the quality of the water.
Thatās much more more concise way to say it, lol.
Shame that some would pour bleach in it anyway so certain people canāt swim though.
Thankfully most civilized nations allow paying cash instead of using the pissed in pool
Personally I think the Australian-style system is better than the UK-style system.
This would work better in the US too where there is a vast private system. It allows for those who want to to pay more and jump into private or wait it out and it be free and you can go between either with some of the public subsidy going to private as theyāve removed a burden on the public system too.
Same with GPs, some private, some bulk-billed (free). Some things should be funded more than Australia though and more like UK inc. ambulances and dental. But UK is very much āonly publicā or āonly privateā, never mixed like in Australia and thatās what makes it a good, if slightly more complicated, system. Ireland, NZ and Franceās systems are very similar to Australiaās.
US should look into it. I think it would work better for them, especially with the private hospital networks currently operating, rather than a full public system.
āMedicare for All means healthcare for everyone, like public school is free for every kid,ā Khanna wrote on social media. āPrivate insurance can still exist on top of it, just like private school still exists.ā
The Medicare for All bills introduced in the House and Senate by Rep. Pramila Jayapal(D-Wash.) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) would cover virtually all medically necessary healthcare, including doctor visits, hospital stays, prescription drugs, dental and vision care, and long-term care.
Your country could easily pay for it by just taxing your billionaires
Or by spending the same amount they currently do.
We would ultimately be spending less
Public school is free for every kid. Accept the lunch fees, the supplies that get pushed onto the teachers when parents canāt afford them, technology fees, sports fees, transportation fees, field trip fees, and anywhere the state can suck away funding from mostly non white schools that are underfunded because of property values and property tax structures that fund them. Resulting in a city with a high school tennis court and swimming pool; next to a city with students using history books from before 9/11.
So, yeah, Iād like Medicare for all to NOT be like public schools. Iād rather it more like current Medicare. But, for all. And fix public schools too.
To be clear itās maga that sabotages and sucks funding away, not some big bad state. Some states have school meals for all because a Dem majority passed it. Some states have healthcare for all incomes and help for higher education, all driven by Dems and good policies. Not perfect, but they try to help people while maga opposes the things that are proven to work.
Public schools should have the same quality of resources and states need to educate better, but since itās up to each state and some donāt value education much so they donāt fund it. All schools should teach critical thinking and Saganās The Demon Haunted World. Show how dualistic systems, family dysfunction cycles, ACE scores and artificial scarcity reduces social mobility, damages mental health and self-confidence, and ways to overcome the damage. People need knowledge, agency and autonomy to escape and do better. Knowledge is power, but too many reject it to fit in, and they and their offspring often suffer for it, and the tax base stays low rather than grow.
I think youāre confusing maga with capitalism. Or blaming the currently active right wing movement for the larger issues with neoliberalsim and austerity measures.
Maga didnāt invent charging kids for lunch or charter schools. Politics didnāt start when you started paying attention to it. The problems with capital attempting to suck profit from every portion of public service has been around long before maga and has been historically a bipartisan process since Reagan and Clinton.
AcceptExcept the lunch feesFTFY
lunch fees, the supplies that get pushed onto the teachers when parents canāt afford them, technology fees, sports fees, transportation fees, field trip fees, and anywhere the state can suck away funding from mostly non white schools that are underfunded because of property values and property tax structures that fund them.
So, better to just have people go bankrupt in the hospital bed while theyāre in a comma?
Iād rather it more like current Medicare.
Boomers are really pulling up the ladder behind them.
deleted by creator
There are plenty of states and schools that charge for bus pickup. Hawaii being a literal state wide mandate. But even California allows it for public schools.
Technology fees are everywhere mate. Hell, there are schools requiring online homework programs that use private institutions programs and require a software license.
I donāt think youāve been paying attention to the clusterfuck of awful unregulated public schools that exist. Your personal experience from your childhood is not a good way to assume the world works.
Edit: looks like you deleted. Guess you did a quick Google search. Respect.
Yep I double checked and deleted about a minute after posting. My home state and surrounding did not charge for those things.
Honestly Iām just curious how you saw and replied to a comment I deleted 13hrs before your reply.
The way admins sway the stability of healthcare, it is understandable why we are where we are.
It needs to be codified and protected.
From what Iāve read, in books like ādying of whitenessā and āthe sum of usā, many people in this country do not want that.
They donāt want those people to have nice things. Theyād rather fill in the town swimming pool so no one can swim, than let those people enjoy it, too.
Sometimes itās malice. Sometimes itās zero-sum thinking. Sometimes itās just stupid. But thatās how many people think.
So I think this framing wonāt win them over, because while it sounds nice and good and fair, theyāre assholes. Youād probably have more success focusing on how it benefits them personally.
Most Americans, and certainly the overwhelming majority of Americans that would ever vote Democrat, already support universal healthcare. The effect here is some combination of sweetening the pill for moderates and plain political posturing (irrespective of Ro Khannaās actual intentions); the filling in swimming pools people are already lost to any cause that furthers human dignity.
Itās a lot of people, but by no means the majority. And those assholes mostly vote Republican already, anyways.











