The only people with an āobsessionā on that topic is the unhinged right wing. How does āmen in womenās sportsā keep coming up as a topic for them? It should not even be in the top 100 list of things to care about, but it seems to be nearly ALL the right wing authoritarians talk about. Itās like the gay marriage fear-mongering of about 20 years ago.
It should not even be in the top 100 list of things to care about
Fucking obsessed about a few dozen trans girls in a few very minor sports competitions. Not even exaggerating there ā the total number of trans girls even attempting to compete in womenās sports is literally a few dozen at most.
I donāt typically talk to people who care, but I have to wonder. How many have actually met a trans person trying to compete.
Not some hypothetical, or friend of a friend. Actually met one. I bet that 99% would say zero. I wonder if we can get some traction helping people realize itās a boogeyman under the bed.
Itās the razor blade in Halloween candy. Satanic panic.
Also, I wonder how many of the people concerned about trans women in womenās sports have ever actually participated in a womenās sporting game of any kind ā even as a TV spectator.
For most of them, Iām betting that if it werenāt for trans women, they never would have been even thinking about womenās sports in the first place.
Iāve used the āare the men in womenās sports in the room with us right now?ā question a few times IRL. It was not an appreciated question.
Trying to explain stupid moral panic things to these types is hard, because a whole lot of them are completely unaware that satanic panic was a thing, and if they are aware of it, they likely still cling to the bullshit tenets of those times. I worked with people in the late 00ās that still believed in that shit. Iām 100% certain if I were to talk to those same people today, they would wax on about the dangers of men in womenās sports.
I remember when Iād see someone passing around that stupid āblue star tattoo LSDā thing IRL at work, in the 90s. As a kid in the 70s, I thought it was highly sus. Since it was the 90s, and the net was a thing then, I tried to point these people at resources showing it was an urban legend. I got lots of side-eye as someone that ādidnāt care about kidsā instead of any of them being convinced. The flyers were still passed around, even put up in the lunchroom bulletin board. Sigh.
I remember as a kid, another moral panic was video games (arcade games). One associate of my mother (my mother thought the lady was unhinged and I think sheās right) was telling everyone that āall the profits from video games goes to the Satanic churchā.
It still makes me laugh to think that olā Anton LaVey was somehow behind Pac-Man and Space Invaders. But I bet if that lady is still alive today, sheās clutching her pearls about the trans.
I know some trans people. They were not out or transitioned or anything like that at a time when they could have played in girls or boys sports, so any sports they played were on the teams these people would want them to be on anyway. Donāt forget that it has to be a trans kid who is into sports where there is some perceived biological advantage or something and the kid transitions before they graduate high school. And presumably they need to be MTF because everyone forgets FTM exists, and itās hard to imagine that MTF kids are going to be really into girls football or something like that.
I know quite a few trans individuals who made the transition in both directions.
Essentially all of them did so in adulthood and absolutely none of them were into sports. It seems just such a minority even within the trans community to be in high school, have transitioned, and heavily into sports.
But the right wing media is intentionally bringing it up over and over. And the viewers conflates the frequency the media talks about it with the frequency of occurrence. I doubt itās possible to really get through to some of these people the fallacy they have fallen victim to. A good number I doubt Iād be able to even get to understand what a fallacy is.
I think I remember on a podcast that in one of the areas where people were drafting anti-trans laws in relation to sports, they might as well name the individuals involved, since the number was so low.
Imagine being such a fucking hateful dumbass that youād put all that effort into writing an initiative to target a handful of people out of millions (assuming it was a state with millions in it, might have been some backwater like Wyoming, I cannot remember).
Republicans see womenās sports as soft core porn and donāt want to get a boner to a trans woman because theyāre terrified of anyone even suggesting theyāre gay.
Itās insane that anyone buys that any of them give a single shit about womenās sports. Itās all such a stupid fucking pantomime, and people somehow believe it. Thatās how stupid Republicans are.
The people who complain about transwomen in womenās sports donāt even care about womenās sports. They can only jerk off to men in tights pouncing on each other for a football.
The trans cancelled all our flights!
The only people with an āobsessionā on that topic is the unhinged right wing. How does āmen in womenās sportsā keep coming up as a topic for them? It should not even be in the top 100 list of things to care about, but it seems to be nearly ALL the right wing authoritarians talk about. Itās like the gay marriage fear-mongering of about 20 years ago.
Fucking obsessed about a few dozen trans girls in a few very minor sports competitions. Not even exaggerating there ā the total number of trans girls even attempting to compete in womenās sports is literally a few dozen at most.
I donāt typically talk to people who care, but I have to wonder. How many have actually met a trans person trying to compete.
Not some hypothetical, or friend of a friend. Actually met one. I bet that 99% would say zero. I wonder if we can get some traction helping people realize itās a boogeyman under the bed.
Itās the razor blade in Halloween candy. Satanic panic.
Also, I wonder how many of the people concerned about trans women in womenās sports have ever actually participated in a womenās sporting game of any kind ā even as a TV spectator.
For most of them, Iām betting that if it werenāt for trans women, they never would have been even thinking about womenās sports in the first place.
Iāve used the āare the men in womenās sports in the room with us right now?ā question a few times IRL. It was not an appreciated question.
Trying to explain stupid moral panic things to these types is hard, because a whole lot of them are completely unaware that satanic panic was a thing, and if they are aware of it, they likely still cling to the bullshit tenets of those times. I worked with people in the late 00ās that still believed in that shit. Iām 100% certain if I were to talk to those same people today, they would wax on about the dangers of men in womenās sports.
I remember when Iād see someone passing around that stupid āblue star tattoo LSDā thing IRL at work, in the 90s. As a kid in the 70s, I thought it was highly sus. Since it was the 90s, and the net was a thing then, I tried to point these people at resources showing it was an urban legend. I got lots of side-eye as someone that ādidnāt care about kidsā instead of any of them being convinced. The flyers were still passed around, even put up in the lunchroom bulletin board. Sigh.
I remember as a kid, another moral panic was video games (arcade games). One associate of my mother (my mother thought the lady was unhinged and I think sheās right) was telling everyone that āall the profits from video games goes to the Satanic churchā.
It still makes me laugh to think that olā Anton LaVey was somehow behind Pac-Man and Space Invaders. But I bet if that lady is still alive today, sheās clutching her pearls about the trans.
I know some trans people. They were not out or transitioned or anything like that at a time when they could have played in girls or boys sports, so any sports they played were on the teams these people would want them to be on anyway. Donāt forget that it has to be a trans kid who is into sports where there is some perceived biological advantage or something and the kid transitions before they graduate high school. And presumably they need to be MTF because everyone forgets FTM exists, and itās hard to imagine that MTF kids are going to be really into girls football or something like that.
I know quite a few trans individuals who made the transition in both directions.
Essentially all of them did so in adulthood and absolutely none of them were into sports. It seems just such a minority even within the trans community to be in high school, have transitioned, and heavily into sports.
But the right wing media is intentionally bringing it up over and over. And the viewers conflates the frequency the media talks about it with the frequency of occurrence. I doubt itās possible to really get through to some of these people the fallacy they have fallen victim to. A good number I doubt Iād be able to even get to understand what a fallacy is.
I think I remember on a podcast that in one of the areas where people were drafting anti-trans laws in relation to sports, they might as well name the individuals involved, since the number was so low.
Imagine being such a fucking hateful dumbass that youād put all that effort into writing an initiative to target a handful of people out of millions (assuming it was a state with millions in it, might have been some backwater like Wyoming, I cannot remember).
They have a strong desire to establish the ability to look at child genitalia. Just saying.
Republicans see womenās sports as soft core porn and donāt want to get a boner to a trans woman because theyāre terrified of anyone even suggesting theyāre gay.
Iām pretty sure this is actually true for a lot of them. Theyāre terrified of āaccidentallyā finding trans woman attractive.
spot on
That would not make them gay but they are too ignorant either way.
Iām starting to think some conservatives are just ashamed of their secret fetish for males in skirts
I swear a lot of transphobes main issue with some of us seems to be that hormones work
Itās insane that anyone buys that any of them give a single shit about womenās sports. Itās all such a stupid fucking pantomime, and people somehow believe it. Thatās how stupid Republicans are.
The people who complain about transwomen in womenās sports donāt even care about womenās sports. They can only jerk off to men in tights pouncing on each other for a football.