Code as Art I covered this before in Art or tool? If you think of software as artistic output then generated software isn't real because it doesn't have the creative ineffability that's a sign of true art. There's no argument against this one except that the people who want software typically aren't paying for artworks,...
I don’t like AI coding, but I can’t say it’s not useful. Most of the arguments in this article can be disarmed by taking the abstraction “one step up”. LLM generated modules and software, microservices, whatever your level of abstraction… now need to be composited together. You go and deal with higher order problems, factories, generation, etc.
Is it a way to develop critical bits of code, depths of your business logic? Absolutely not. Can it solve a lot of boilerplate and support logic? Absolutely yes.
Seeing “AI Companies as Bad Actors”… can’t fully disagree there. There’s far too many far too dodgy things about these businesses, and I trust them as far as I can audit them (not very far). And the missing argument’s the cognitive decline of using these things to think for us. I try to keep myself sharp by still manually doing a fair amount of things in my life. I refuse to automate everything - especially the stuff I do for fun. Having an LLM manage hobby-adjacent stuff is a quick trip to burnout land, especially once fixing the thing becomes “the hobby”… and it does.
I don’t like AI coding, but I can’t say it’s not useful. Most of the arguments in this article can be disarmed by taking the abstraction “one step up”. LLM generated modules and software, microservices, whatever your level of abstraction… now need to be composited together. You go and deal with higher order problems, factories, generation, etc.
Is it a way to develop critical bits of code, depths of your business logic? Absolutely not. Can it solve a lot of boilerplate and support logic? Absolutely yes.
Seeing “AI Companies as Bad Actors”… can’t fully disagree there. There’s far too many far too dodgy things about these businesses, and I trust them as far as I can audit them (not very far). And the missing argument’s the cognitive decline of using these things to think for us. I try to keep myself sharp by still manually doing a fair amount of things in my life. I refuse to automate everything - especially the stuff I do for fun. Having an LLM manage hobby-adjacent stuff is a quick trip to burnout land, especially once fixing the thing becomes “the hobby”… and it does.
score 1 · canonical