• There is an impossibility here of catering to those who open a link, see any amount of LLM-generated content, close the tab, and flag the post as spam, and those who don’t mind it/are excited about the results regardless. I’m hopeful this will cut down on much of the noise (esp. slopped together projects w/o explanation), but I suspect that posts detailing work only accomplished as a result of LLM use will now slip through, and I would definitely appreciate a tag for this as well. I do think LLM usage is shameful practice, and I do not want to engage with it, and I’m far from alone in that, and I’m certainly not leading crowds with pitchforks to those websites. I still believe there should be some such tag such that we can filter away such posts if we don’t want to engage with them.


    score 1 · canonical

    • lobsters__355e3b@crustaceanson.theshelf.topOPM
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 个月前

      It’s unfortunately been pretty difficult to try and keep the properties of the tag without also bringing along the negative externalities it’s existence has caused. I’ve thrown around the idea of adopting the ATproto “stackable moderation”, which would offer a better way to apply these overlay filtering long term, but that’s gated behind some serious technical work and a few UX issues.

      With regards to posts detailing the work which was only accomplished as a result of LLM usage, my suspicion is that the post themselves will also only be acompished as a result of LLM usage and already fall under our definition of “spam”.


      score 5 · canonical

      • With regards to posts detailing the work which was only accomplished as a result of LLM usage, my suspicion is that the post themselves will also only be acompished as a result of LLM usage

        This often holds but the number of cases where it does not is numerous. With this information, the best choice for us who do not wish to see the results of LLM usage is to flag even human-written posts about LLM usage as spam. There is no longer other recourse.


        score 4 · canonical

      • With regards to posts detailing the work which was only accomplished as a result of LLM usage, my suspicion is that the post themselves will also only be acompished as a result of LLM usage and already fall under our definition of “spam”.

        Unless I’m misreading you I don’t think this is going to be consistently true. Like, the proximate cause of this latest kerfuffle: I think it is fair to say the result it describes was a result of LLM usage, but the post certainly had meaningful human authorship.


        score 2 · canonical

    • lobsters__zk@crustaceanson.theshelf.topM
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 个月前

      work only accomplished as a result of LLM use will now slip through, and I would definitely appreciate a tag for this as well.

      If such content is welcome on this site, then I definitely agree with this, I’d be filtering that out by hiding this hypothetical tag. I think this is what a lot of people wanted or assumed the vibecoding tag was for… Like the post says, it became an overloaded tag.

      I am assuming the mods will try out this new ai-tooling tag and then will be willing to reassess a little bit down the line. Hopefully this second tag for work only accomplished as a result of LLM will be considered. Again, assuming such content is allowed on this site — which I’m personally not clear on whether or not it is.


      score 3 · canonical

      • I loathe this argument. Sure, you are functionally correct, but you can never know if anyone is lying to you. I hope people would have the common decency to disclose, and otherwise when I find out they haven’t, they end up in my ublock list. I’ll miss some things, perhaps, but that misrepresentation is their failing, not mine.

        Besides, it is almost always completely obvious when people don’t disclose.


        score 3 · canonical

      • Why does that matter? If you need to hide it it’s probably because it’s a low quality project. The recompilation scene isn’t shy about AI use. It’s seriously impressive. I just don’t want to see it, even ignoring ethical issues (and I won’t), it has nothing to do with how I interact with programming. I have as much use for it as emacs posts. Just let me filter it.


        score 1 · canonical