It’s well defined in copyright law already but the specifics may need discussion in court in some cases. A camera is a tool and the majority of the choices in the output came from a human. If the camera was mounted on a device controlled by some form of AI, it would likely be considered not created by a human and thus uncopyrightable.
it would likely be considered not created by a human
I’m not criticizing you at all, but you refer to an important point. As I understand it, your “likely be considered” is true, and there’s things of interest inside it. The USA legal system is adversarial, and a trial of some sort would be necessary to ultimately settle the question. Despite everyone’s best efforts to stay inside the law, sometimes trials give an apparently bad result. ABC vs Aereo seems like an example. Aereo went to great lengths to stay inside what statutes and previous cases had laid out, but still lost, leading engineers to decide that using a very long antenna cable could constitute copyright infringement. So “likely” is the correct phrasing, and copyright is very odd.
Like photo generated with Camara? How do you define written by human?
score -1 · canonical
It’s well defined in copyright law already but the specifics may need discussion in court in some cases. A camera is a tool and the majority of the choices in the output came from a human. If the camera was mounted on a device controlled by some form of AI, it would likely be considered not created by a human and thus uncopyrightable.
score 2 · canonical
I’m not criticizing you at all, but you refer to an important point. As I understand it, your “likely be considered” is true, and there’s things of interest inside it. The USA legal system is adversarial, and a trial of some sort would be necessary to ultimately settle the question. Despite everyone’s best efforts to stay inside the law, sometimes trials give an apparently bad result. ABC vs Aereo seems like an example. Aereo went to great lengths to stay inside what statutes and previous cases had laid out, but still lost, leading engineers to decide that using a very long antenna cable could constitute copyright infringement. So “likely” is the correct phrasing, and copyright is very odd.
score 1 · canonical