• Thanks for posting this. When reading this article, I was thinking the general thrust seems right, but something bugged me about it. I think you nailed it.

    However, I also think that the sooner we move beyond copyright on software, the better. Copyleft was invented to prevent closing up of code written by people who wanted their code to remain open. If, in a post-LLM society, all code would be considered uncopyrightable, we no longer need copyleft or open source as it currently exists.

    I am not sure about the end result though. One would be able to freely copy any and all software, but that no longer matters in this day and age with SaaS. Being able to inspect and modify and then redistribute software is way more important IMO. But again, everything moving to online silos means the software itself doesn’t really matter that much anymore.


    score 1 · canonical

    • Copyleft was invented to prevent closing up of code written by people who wanted their code to remain open

      No, copyright licenses like the GPL were created so that non-lawyers had a way of sharing software in a way that prevented companies from taking it and claiming that because it was public, it was public domain. Stallman started this because he did not like the fact that all software you got had no source code available, and wanted to be able to write code where the source was available without allow companies to take it and incorporate into their own software without giving it back That required significant legal work to ensure the license was sufficient to cover all the potential abuses of companies, and could be enforced (you can easily write unenforceable terms).

      The important thing is that if you remove copyright then you cannot own source code, if you cannot own it, you cannot restrict how it is used. e.g. absent copyright you roll back the entire concept of open source code to what companies want to be able to do: claim that public source code is public domain, and so they are free to use it as they want and not ever release the code they derive from it.

      The ability to copyright law is the only thing that gives any OSS license any ability to put requirements on users - even simple acknowledgement of the use of the code.


      score 2 · canonical

      • that public source code is public domain, and so they are free to use it as they want and not ever release the code they derive from it.

        If it were truly public domain they should have less reason to keep it to themselves. If copyright on code were to abolished, at the same time we should require all code to be public.


        score 2 · canonical