• I would put the beginning a bit further in the past. When management found out they could hire Fullstack Developers, many frontend developers were not happy with working on the backend and vice versa. Then came DevOps and admins and fullstack developers were not happy to get a even wider spectrum of work. With DevOpsSec the accountability grew even wider with no compensation but unhappiness. Labour cost arbitrage it its finest.

    A large cohort of unhappy people in software were then confronted with AI/LLM and some found happiness again and some lost it.

    All this analysis and retrospective is fine but to tell the whole story you have to follow the money. The wages, the earnings and the winners of this decade of change.


    score 1 · canonical

  • It wasn’t always like this. Only 12 years ago, tech was a different industry.

    I’ve been at it 30+ years and I think this article is a little bit too rosy on the past. Let’s not forget, say, Therac-25.

    There were bumps with each technology transition. If anything I think the argument is that this is the same again (and that we failed to learn from the past).


    score 4 · canonical

    • The left-pad incident happened in 2016, so about a decade ago. Back then, this was a novelty and caught most people by surprise. The world definitely used to be different back then, and while I agree that the problem already existed back then, it exists today at a scale that is larger by orders of magnitude. Software development has become more accessible, more ubiquitous, more low-skill and more rushed.


      score 1 · canonical

      • I think your terms/phrases of “larger by orders of magnitude” and “more rushed” probably encapsulate more accurately all that is happening. Too much is forced to get done and at such a fast pace even if done by highly competent people, its tough to stay on top of.


        score 2 · canonical

    • The statement is correct - we didn’t really glue shitloads of stuff together as much 12 years ago as we do now. But you are also right, in the past we really didn’t do better than now. SQL injections were rampant in the 90s and early zeroes, and buffer overruns before that.


      score 1 · canonical

      • The consequence for an average consumers feels so wildly different tho(I agree with what you’re saying here), if I want less software in my appliances my options are severely limited, while their practical value of doing the thing hasn’t changed that much. Whereas if my Windows 98 box was glitching, I’d just go find an office.

        I’m generalizing a bit here, but I feel like it’s hard to improve/change systems where the incentives are so funky.


        score 1 · canonical